Talk:Jeevan Sangeet (जीवन संगीत): Difference between revisions

From The Sannyas Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
No edit summary
 
(19 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
===Current Understanding===
{| class="wikitable"
! event !! audio,<br>OshoWorld !! audio,<br>Osho.com !! 2018 e-book '''(*1)''' !! Shailendra's PDF !! Oshoganga '''(*2)''' !! Osho.com library !! OshoWorld e-book !! Dates & Places
|-
| [[Jeevan Sangeet ~ 01]] || #1<br>incomplete || 1. पहला सूत्र: आत्म-स्वतंत्रता का बोध<br>incomplete || 1. पहला सूत्र : आत्म-स्वतंत्रता का बोध || 1. पहला सूत्रः आत्म-स्वतंत्रता का बोध<br>incomplete || 1. (no title)<br>incomplete || 1. पहला सूत्र: आत्म-स्वतंत्रता का बोध<br>incomplete || 1. (no title) (p.1-18)<br>incomplete || 3 Jun 1969 pm, [[wikipedia:Udaipur | Udaipur]]
|-
| [[Jeevan Sangeet ~ 02]] || #2 || 2. दूसरा सूत्र: खोजें मत, ठहरें  || 2. दूसरा सूत्र: खोजें मत, ठहरें || 2. दूसरा सूत्रः खोजें मत, ठहरें || 2. (no title) || 2. दूसरा सूत्र: खोजें मत, ठहरें || 2. (no title) (p.18-33) || 4 Jun 1969 am, [[wikipedia:Udaipur | Udaipur]]
|-
| [[Jeevan Sangeet ~ 03]] '''(*5)''' || ''Upasana Ke Kshan'' #8 || 3. विचार-क्रांति || 3. विचार-क्रांति || 3. विचार-क्रांति ||  || 3. विचार की क्रांति ||  || 4 Jun 1969 om[[Glossary#am om pm xm|**]], [[wikipedia:Udaipur | Udaipur]]
|-
| [[Jeevan Sangeet ~ 04]] || #3 || 4. स्वप्न से जागरण की ओर || 4. स्वप्न से जागरण की और || 4. स्वप्न से जागरण की और || 3. (no title) || 4. स्वप्न से जागरण की ओर || 3. (no title)(p.34-54) || 4 Jun 1969 pm, [[wikipedia:Udaipur | Udaipur]]
|-
| [[Jeevan Sangeet ~ 05]] || #4 || 5. दुख के प्रति जागरण || 5. दुख के प्रति जागरण || 5. दुख के प्रति जागरण || 4. (no title) || 5. दुख के प्रति जागरण || 4. (no title) (p.54-71) || 5 Jun 1969 am, [[wikipedia:Udaipur | Udaipur]]
|-
| [[Jeevan Sangeet ~ 06]] '''(*5)''' || #5 (before 24m 18s)<br>beginning incomplete || 6. समस्त के प्रति प्रेम ही प्रार्थना है (before 24:33)<br>beginning incomplete || 6. समस्त के प्रति प्रेम ही प्रार्थना है ||
* 6. समस्त के प्रति प्रेम ही प्रार्थना है<br>beginning incomplete
* ''Kaha Kahun Us Des Ki'' 5. प्रार्थना क्या है<br>beginning incomplete, missing last sentence<br>Udaipur, 5 Jan 1969, afternooon '''(*3)'''
||
* 5. (no title) (from beginning to last 7 paragraphs)<br>beginning incomplete (this is most complete, like OW audio)
* ''Kaha Kahun Us Des Ki'' 5. प्रार्थना क्या है<br>beginning incomplete, missing last sentence<br>Udaipur, 5 Jan 1969, afternooon '''(*3)'''
|| 6. समस्त के प्रति प्रेम ही प्रार्थना है<br>beginning incomplete || 5. (no title) (first part: p.71-78)<br>beginning incomplete (this is most complete, like OW audio) || 5 Jun 1969 om[[Glossary#am om pm xm|**]], [[wikipedia:Udaipur | Udaipur]]
|-
| [[Upasana Ke Kshan ~ 07]] ||
* #5 (from 24m 18s)<br>end incomplete
* ''Upasana Ke Kshan'' #7 (before 12:26) '''(*4)'''<br>end incomplete, some text is untranscribed in the end
||
* 6. समस्त के प्रति प्रेम ही प्रार्थना है (from 24:33)<br>end incomplete
* ''Upasana Ke Kshan'' 6. उपासना का मतलब: पास बैठना (second part of audio, except last 40sec) '''(*4)'''<br>end incomplete, some text is untranscribed in the end
||  || ''Upasana Ke Kshan'' 7. उपासना का मतलबः पास बैठना<br>end incomplete ||
* 5. (no title) (last 7 paragraphs)<br>this is beginning of the event only
* ''Upasana Ke Kshan'' 7. उपासना का मतलबः पास बैठना<br>end incomplete
|| ''Upasana Ke Kshan'' 7. उपासना का मतलब: पास बैठना<br>end incomplete || 5. (no title) (second part: p.78-79)<br>this is beginning of the event only  || 4 Jun 1969 om [[Glossary#am om pm xm|**]], [[wikipedia:Udaipur | Udaipur]]
|-
| [[Jeevan Sangeet ~ 07]] || #6 || 7. विश्वासः सत्य की खोज में सबसे बड़ी बाधा || 7. विश्वास: सत्य की खोज में सबसे बड़ी बाधा || 7. विश्वासः सत्य की खोज में सबसे बड़ी बाधा || 6. (no title) || 7. विश्वास: सत्य की खोज में सबसे बड़ी बाधा || 6. (no title) (p.80-99) || 5 Jun 1969 pm, [[wikipedia:Udaipur | Udaipur]]
|-
| [[Jeevan Sangeet ~ 08]] || #7 || 8. प्रार्थना का रहस्य || 8. प्रार्थना का रहस्य || 8. प्रार्थना का रहस्य || 7. (no title) || 8. प्रार्थना का रहस्य || 7. (no title) (p.99-116) || 6 Jun 1969 am , [[wikipedia:Udaipur | Udaipur]]
|-
| [[Jeevan Sangeet ~ 09]] || #8 || 9. क्रांति एक विस्फोट है, ध्यान एक विकास है || 9. क्रांति एक विस्फोट है, ध्यान एक विकास है || 9. क्रांति एक विस्फोट है, ध्यान एक विकास है || 8. (no title) || 9. क्रांति एक विस्फोट है, ध्यान एक विकास है || 8. (no title) (p.117-134) || 6 Jun 1969 om[[Glossary#am om pm xm|**]], [[wikipedia:Udaipur | Udaipur]]
|-
| [[Jeevan Sangeet ~ 10]] || #9<br>missing first word || 10. नये का आमंत्रण<br>"sound dropouts", missing first and last word || 10. नये का आमंत्रण || 10. नये का आमंतत्र || 9. (no title)<br>only first half || 10. नये का आमंत्रण || 9. (no title) (p.134-149)<br>only first half || 6 Jun 1969 pm, [[wikipedia:Udaipur | Udaipur]]
|}
;Notes
:(*1) Comparing of this e-book based on chapter titles only.
:(*2) Cover on Oshoganga doesn't match to its content. Actually it belongs to other book with the same title ''[[Jeevan Sangeet (जीवन संगीत) (4 talks)]]'', 4 talks on Gorakh.
:(*3) Month should be 'June' as stated in 1980 ed. of ''[[Kaha Kahun Us Des Ki (कहा कहूं उस देस की)]]''. It seems OCR error. See footnote (*6) on [[Talk:Kaha Kahun Us Des Ki (कहा कहूं उस देस की)]].
:(*4) This audio is #7 in Khajana collection and from 12:20 there follows small English part from [[Early Talks ~ 01]]:
::"Then you become totally independent. Independence one needs. Outwardly will be gained in any occupation. But an occupation like gardening or farming will do much good. Bodily, mentally and spiritually -- on all layers of life, it will be helpful."
:It is in OshoWorld audio from 12:26. On Osho.com this audio are selling together with previous short audio of ''Upasana'' series.
:(*5) These talks are private judging by their audios and time (afternoon).
===Deliberations===
In a couple of places at Osho World, there were blurbs about ''Sangeet'' which included a mention of Udaipur and "experiments," which sounded a lot like a [[Meditation Camps|meditation camp]]. The only one currently known in Udaipur was May 14-17, 1966, but others may come to light. (If it was indeed so. One of the OW places cited had some fairly flaky info along with the Udaipur mention and might be discounted on that basis.)
In a couple of places at Osho World, there were blurbs about ''Sangeet'' which included a mention of Udaipur and "experiments," which sounded a lot like a [[Meditation Camps|meditation camp]]. The only one currently known in Udaipur was May 14-17, 1966, but others may come to light. (If it was indeed so. One of the OW places cited had some fairly flaky info along with the Udaipur mention and might be discounted on that basis.)


Regarding the editions, there was some variable information connected with both the Rebel and Diamond editions, especially the Diamond one. Some places had different ISBNs (9798171825294), page counts (130) and pub dates (2009). And the Rebel edition had a different page count somewhere, now lost. Quite a difference there between the two editions as well (228 compared to 136). (fwiw) -- [[User:Sarlo|Sarlo]] ([[User talk:Sarlo|talk]]) 15:58, 7 June 2014 (PDT)
Regarding the editions, there was some variable information connected with both the Rebel and Diamond editions, especially the Diamond one. Some places had different ISBNs (9798171825294), page counts (130) and pub dates (2009). And the Rebel edition had a different page count somewhere, now lost. Quite a difference there between the two editions as well (228 compared to 136). (fwiw) -- [[User:Sarlo|Sarlo]] ([[User talk:Sarlo|talk]]) 15:58, 7 June 2014 (PDT)
----
----
Diamond edition is another book with different contents - ch.13-16 of ''[[Maro He Jogi Maro (मरौ हे जोगी मरौ)]]''. I am going to move it to new page - ''[[Jeevan Sangeet (जीवन संगीत) (2)]]''.  
Diamond edition is another book with different contents - ch.13-16 of ''[[Maro He Jogi Maro (मरौ हे जोगी मरौ)]]''. I am going to move it to new page - ''[[Jeevan Sangeet (जीवन संगीत) (4 talks)]]''.
----
1969 year stated in osho.com library.--DhyanAntar 14:40, 29 October 2020 (UTC)
----
Extracts from text (source Shailendra's PDF):
 
:Ch.1: first evening talk of 3-days series, night meditation in the end. "I miss a short story, let me start the three-day discussions." "The soul of man is easily free, calm, blissful. Unhappy, you are planning. You are in bondage, you have made handcuffs. You are suffering, you seem very skilled in causing trouble. It is your skill that you are causing trouble. It is your workmanship that you are creating misery. And you are not ordinary artisans, because on that soul you build a house of sorrow, that soul is hard to touch. And you are not an ordinary smart blacksmith, you place chains on a soul on which no one has ever been chained, nor can sit. And the fun is fun. They make the chains themselves and then move around those chains, how do we get rid of them? Need some way - how to calm down, how to be blissful, how to get out of sorrow?
:"In this primary discussion on the first day, I want to tell you that..." "In these three days, it has to be searched intensively. Every day I will talk about its different sources. But all the sutras will be taken this way. I will push from different place. But the bang will be the one to bang the same place."
 
:Ch.2: starts "It can be held unmanned which is in prison; He can be freed. One who is asleep can be woken up; But it is very difficult to awaken someone who is awake and in the illusion that I am asleep. And it is very difficult to open one who is free and thinks that I am bound. And around which there are no chains and with closed eyes, I dream that I am tied in chains, and you ask how to break these chains? How to be free How to leave? So there is a lot of difficulty.
:"I told you something on the first thread in this regard. (Reference to ch.1.) The soul of a human being is not free, and we are sitting on it as a layer. Do not make human soul independent. All you need to know is that the soul is free.
:"Today, in this second sutra, it is necessary to point again from the other direction. There is only one moon, gestures can be made with many fingers. The same is true, one can enter through many gates. In the second sutra it is necessary to understand what we are looking for?"
:"That's why the second sutra wants to tell you: Don't search, stay! Do not run, stop!"
:In the end: "And then we will sit at night... See you again for that jump at night." (It seems reference to ch.4.)
 
:Ch.3: q/a.
 
:Ch.4: night meditation in the end.
 
:Ch.5: morning talk. "In this meeting of this morning, I would like to say something..." In the end: "At night, we will also sit for the experiment how to do this experiment and enter inside." (It can be reference to ch.7.)
 
:Ch.6: q/a. Starts by "First of all, a friend has asked that yesterday I said to leave the search. (Reference to ch.2.) And if we leave the search, then science will not be born." After response to q.1: "The other friend has asked many questions. Take one or two questions from it, then those who remain will take tomorrow." (It seems reference to ch.9.) Then q.2 follows. During response to q.2: "One small thing then let me finish my talk. Then tomorrow, the questions that remain, we will talk." Ends by: "Then, and those who are left will talk tomorrow." (It seems reference to ch.9.)
 
:Ch.7: night meditation in the end. In beginning: "Today evening I will discuss another direction and door in search of that bliss, that elixir."
 
:Ch.8: q/a. It starts by "Many questions have been asked by friends regarding the three-day discussions.". "If we raise a naked woman in '''Udaipur''' in India, how many people will come to see?" In the end: "A few more questions remain, I will talk to you about the evening." (It seems reference to ch.10.)
 
:Ch.9: q/a.
 
:Ch.10: q/a, last talk for 4 days. Starts by "Many questions have been sent by friends regarding the three days of discussions. I will try to answer as many questions as possible." And ends by "Heard my words with so much peace and so much love these four days".
 
Talks look as in chronological order. 3 talks per day starting with evening talk.
 
Summary of sources: osho.com library - '1969', [[Osho's Itinerary]] (Udaipur 3-6 Jun 1969), 1980ed. of ''[[Kaha Kahun Us Des Ki (कहा कहूं उस देस की)]]'' (date for ch.6 - 5 Jun 1969 afternoon, Udaipur), text of talks (its unity states on 4 days and found confirmation of place), - all these give strong feeling and fitting in Timeline for 3 Jun 1969 pm - 6 Jun 1969 pm.
 
--DhyanAntar 09:21, 30 October 2020 (UTC)
----
----
:विषय सूची (TOC):
It needs OW ebook. That site is now under maintenance.--DhyanAntar 11:58, 2 November 2020 (UTC)
:1: पहला सूत्र: आत्म-स्वतंत्रता का बोध
:2: दूसरा सूत्र: खोजें मत, ठहरें
:3: विचार-क्रांति
:4. स्वप्न से जागरण की और
:5. दुख के प्रति जागरण
:6. समस्त के प्रति प्रेम ही प्रार्थना है
:7. विश्वास: सत्य की खोज में सबसे बड़ी बाधा
:8. प्रार्थना का रहस्य
:9: क्रांति एक विस्फोट है, ध्यान एक विकास है
:10: नये का आमंत्रण

Latest revision as of 08:40, 23 August 2022

Current Understanding

event audio,
OshoWorld
audio,
Osho.com
2018 e-book (*1) Shailendra's PDF Oshoganga (*2) Osho.com library OshoWorld e-book Dates & Places
Jeevan Sangeet ~ 01 #1
incomplete
1. पहला सूत्र: आत्म-स्वतंत्रता का बोध
incomplete
1. पहला सूत्र : आत्म-स्वतंत्रता का बोध 1. पहला सूत्रः आत्म-स्वतंत्रता का बोध
incomplete
1. (no title)
incomplete
1. पहला सूत्र: आत्म-स्वतंत्रता का बोध
incomplete
1. (no title) (p.1-18)
incomplete
3 Jun 1969 pm, Udaipur
Jeevan Sangeet ~ 02 #2 2. दूसरा सूत्र: खोजें मत, ठहरें 2. दूसरा सूत्र: खोजें मत, ठहरें 2. दूसरा सूत्रः खोजें मत, ठहरें 2. (no title) 2. दूसरा सूत्र: खोजें मत, ठहरें 2. (no title) (p.18-33) 4 Jun 1969 am, Udaipur
Jeevan Sangeet ~ 03 (*5) Upasana Ke Kshan #8 3. विचार-क्रांति 3. विचार-क्रांति 3. विचार-क्रांति 3. विचार की क्रांति 4 Jun 1969 om**, Udaipur
Jeevan Sangeet ~ 04 #3 4. स्वप्न से जागरण की ओर 4. स्वप्न से जागरण की और 4. स्वप्न से जागरण की और 3. (no title) 4. स्वप्न से जागरण की ओर 3. (no title)(p.34-54) 4 Jun 1969 pm, Udaipur
Jeevan Sangeet ~ 05 #4 5. दुख के प्रति जागरण 5. दुख के प्रति जागरण 5. दुख के प्रति जागरण 4. (no title) 5. दुख के प्रति जागरण 4. (no title) (p.54-71) 5 Jun 1969 am, Udaipur
Jeevan Sangeet ~ 06 (*5) #5 (before 24m 18s)
beginning incomplete
6. समस्त के प्रति प्रेम ही प्रार्थना है (before 24:33)
beginning incomplete
6. समस्त के प्रति प्रेम ही प्रार्थना है
  • 6. समस्त के प्रति प्रेम ही प्रार्थना है
    beginning incomplete
  • Kaha Kahun Us Des Ki 5. प्रार्थना क्या है
    beginning incomplete, missing last sentence
    Udaipur, 5 Jan 1969, afternooon (*3)
  • 5. (no title) (from beginning to last 7 paragraphs)
    beginning incomplete (this is most complete, like OW audio)
  • Kaha Kahun Us Des Ki 5. प्रार्थना क्या है
    beginning incomplete, missing last sentence
    Udaipur, 5 Jan 1969, afternooon (*3)
6. समस्त के प्रति प्रेम ही प्रार्थना है
beginning incomplete
5. (no title) (first part: p.71-78)
beginning incomplete (this is most complete, like OW audio)
5 Jun 1969 om**, Udaipur
Upasana Ke Kshan ~ 07
  • #5 (from 24m 18s)
    end incomplete
  • Upasana Ke Kshan #7 (before 12:26) (*4)
    end incomplete, some text is untranscribed in the end
  • 6. समस्त के प्रति प्रेम ही प्रार्थना है (from 24:33)
    end incomplete
  • Upasana Ke Kshan 6. उपासना का मतलब: पास बैठना (second part of audio, except last 40sec) (*4)
    end incomplete, some text is untranscribed in the end
Upasana Ke Kshan 7. उपासना का मतलबः पास बैठना
end incomplete
  • 5. (no title) (last 7 paragraphs)
    this is beginning of the event only
  • Upasana Ke Kshan 7. उपासना का मतलबः पास बैठना
    end incomplete
Upasana Ke Kshan 7. उपासना का मतलब: पास बैठना
end incomplete
5. (no title) (second part: p.78-79)
this is beginning of the event only
4 Jun 1969 om **, Udaipur
Jeevan Sangeet ~ 07 #6 7. विश्वासः सत्य की खोज में सबसे बड़ी बाधा 7. विश्वास: सत्य की खोज में सबसे बड़ी बाधा 7. विश्वासः सत्य की खोज में सबसे बड़ी बाधा 6. (no title) 7. विश्वास: सत्य की खोज में सबसे बड़ी बाधा 6. (no title) (p.80-99) 5 Jun 1969 pm, Udaipur
Jeevan Sangeet ~ 08 #7 8. प्रार्थना का रहस्य 8. प्रार्थना का रहस्य 8. प्रार्थना का रहस्य 7. (no title) 8. प्रार्थना का रहस्य 7. (no title) (p.99-116) 6 Jun 1969 am , Udaipur
Jeevan Sangeet ~ 09 #8 9. क्रांति एक विस्फोट है, ध्यान एक विकास है 9. क्रांति एक विस्फोट है, ध्यान एक विकास है 9. क्रांति एक विस्फोट है, ध्यान एक विकास है 8. (no title) 9. क्रांति एक विस्फोट है, ध्यान एक विकास है 8. (no title) (p.117-134) 6 Jun 1969 om**, Udaipur
Jeevan Sangeet ~ 10 #9
missing first word
10. नये का आमंत्रण
"sound dropouts", missing first and last word
10. नये का आमंत्रण 10. नये का आमंतत्र 9. (no title)
only first half
10. नये का आमंत्रण 9. (no title) (p.134-149)
only first half
6 Jun 1969 pm, Udaipur
Notes
(*1) Comparing of this e-book based on chapter titles only.
(*2) Cover on Oshoganga doesn't match to its content. Actually it belongs to other book with the same title Jeevan Sangeet (जीवन संगीत) (4 talks), 4 talks on Gorakh.
(*3) Month should be 'June' as stated in 1980 ed. of Kaha Kahun Us Des Ki (कहा कहूं उस देस की). It seems OCR error. See footnote (*6) on Talk:Kaha Kahun Us Des Ki (कहा कहूं उस देस की).
(*4) This audio is #7 in Khajana collection and from 12:20 there follows small English part from Early Talks ~ 01:
"Then you become totally independent. Independence one needs. Outwardly will be gained in any occupation. But an occupation like gardening or farming will do much good. Bodily, mentally and spiritually -- on all layers of life, it will be helpful."
It is in OshoWorld audio from 12:26. On Osho.com this audio are selling together with previous short audio of Upasana series.
(*5) These talks are private judging by their audios and time (afternoon).

Deliberations

In a couple of places at Osho World, there were blurbs about Sangeet which included a mention of Udaipur and "experiments," which sounded a lot like a meditation camp. The only one currently known in Udaipur was May 14-17, 1966, but others may come to light. (If it was indeed so. One of the OW places cited had some fairly flaky info along with the Udaipur mention and might be discounted on that basis.)

Regarding the editions, there was some variable information connected with both the Rebel and Diamond editions, especially the Diamond one. Some places had different ISBNs (9798171825294), page counts (130) and pub dates (2009). And the Rebel edition had a different page count somewhere, now lost. Quite a difference there between the two editions as well (228 compared to 136). (fwiw) -- Sarlo (talk) 15:58, 7 June 2014 (PDT)


Diamond edition is another book with different contents - ch.13-16 of Maro He Jogi Maro (मरौ हे जोगी मरौ). I am going to move it to new page - Jeevan Sangeet (जीवन संगीत) (4 talks).


1969 year stated in osho.com library.--DhyanAntar 14:40, 29 October 2020 (UTC)


Extracts from text (source Shailendra's PDF):

Ch.1: first evening talk of 3-days series, night meditation in the end. "I miss a short story, let me start the three-day discussions." "The soul of man is easily free, calm, blissful. Unhappy, you are planning. You are in bondage, you have made handcuffs. You are suffering, you seem very skilled in causing trouble. It is your skill that you are causing trouble. It is your workmanship that you are creating misery. And you are not ordinary artisans, because on that soul you build a house of sorrow, that soul is hard to touch. And you are not an ordinary smart blacksmith, you place chains on a soul on which no one has ever been chained, nor can sit. And the fun is fun. They make the chains themselves and then move around those chains, how do we get rid of them? Need some way - how to calm down, how to be blissful, how to get out of sorrow?
"In this primary discussion on the first day, I want to tell you that..." "In these three days, it has to be searched intensively. Every day I will talk about its different sources. But all the sutras will be taken this way. I will push from different place. But the bang will be the one to bang the same place."
Ch.2: starts "It can be held unmanned which is in prison; He can be freed. One who is asleep can be woken up; But it is very difficult to awaken someone who is awake and in the illusion that I am asleep. And it is very difficult to open one who is free and thinks that I am bound. And around which there are no chains and with closed eyes, I dream that I am tied in chains, and you ask how to break these chains? How to be free How to leave? So there is a lot of difficulty.
"I told you something on the first thread in this regard. (Reference to ch.1.) The soul of a human being is not free, and we are sitting on it as a layer. Do not make human soul independent. All you need to know is that the soul is free.
"Today, in this second sutra, it is necessary to point again from the other direction. There is only one moon, gestures can be made with many fingers. The same is true, one can enter through many gates. In the second sutra it is necessary to understand what we are looking for?"
"That's why the second sutra wants to tell you: Don't search, stay! Do not run, stop!"
In the end: "And then we will sit at night... See you again for that jump at night." (It seems reference to ch.4.)
Ch.3: q/a.
Ch.4: night meditation in the end.
Ch.5: morning talk. "In this meeting of this morning, I would like to say something..." In the end: "At night, we will also sit for the experiment how to do this experiment and enter inside." (It can be reference to ch.7.)
Ch.6: q/a. Starts by "First of all, a friend has asked that yesterday I said to leave the search. (Reference to ch.2.) And if we leave the search, then science will not be born." After response to q.1: "The other friend has asked many questions. Take one or two questions from it, then those who remain will take tomorrow." (It seems reference to ch.9.) Then q.2 follows. During response to q.2: "One small thing then let me finish my talk. Then tomorrow, the questions that remain, we will talk." Ends by: "Then, and those who are left will talk tomorrow." (It seems reference to ch.9.)
Ch.7: night meditation in the end. In beginning: "Today evening I will discuss another direction and door in search of that bliss, that elixir."
Ch.8: q/a. It starts by "Many questions have been asked by friends regarding the three-day discussions.". "If we raise a naked woman in Udaipur in India, how many people will come to see?" In the end: "A few more questions remain, I will talk to you about the evening." (It seems reference to ch.10.)
Ch.9: q/a.
Ch.10: q/a, last talk for 4 days. Starts by "Many questions have been sent by friends regarding the three days of discussions. I will try to answer as many questions as possible." And ends by "Heard my words with so much peace and so much love these four days".

Talks look as in chronological order. 3 talks per day starting with evening talk.

Summary of sources: osho.com library - '1969', Osho's Itinerary (Udaipur 3-6 Jun 1969), 1980ed. of Kaha Kahun Us Des Ki (कहा कहूं उस देस की) (date for ch.6 - 5 Jun 1969 afternoon, Udaipur), text of talks (its unity states on 4 days and found confirmation of place), - all these give strong feeling and fitting in Timeline for 3 Jun 1969 pm - 6 Jun 1969 pm.

--DhyanAntar 09:21, 30 October 2020 (UTC)


It needs OW ebook. That site is now under maintenance.--DhyanAntar 11:58, 2 November 2020 (UTC)