Manuscripts ~ Programmes Timeline Extraction

From The Sannyas Wiki
Revision as of 17:31, 16 July 2019 by Sarlo (talk | contribs)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Jump to: navigation, search

A correspondent has shared his research into Osho's Manuscripts. Some of Osho's early writings have turned out to be fact-based accounts of his travels, speeches, and the events of the time. The research is organized into several batches, corresponding to the particular groups of manuscripts where info was found. All info presented is annotated, ie which sheet of the manuscripts it derives from is clearly indicated, so one can also study them for oneself. In some cases, Osho's notes contain the full text of early unpublished discourses, though not in this batch.

This batch, the third in the series, derives from a small group of just three pages at Manuscripts ~ Programmes. It is particularly short but concentrated, mostly a schedule of talks running from Apr 25 to Aug 10 and another small group from Jan 26 to Feb 6. These manuscripts do not include the year, as it was not needed for Osho's notes about his program for a few months. Comparison with existing Timelines makes 1968 look reasonably likely for the time frame for the first two pages, which are flip sides of each other. The other page, containing notes about the short period from Jan 26 to Feb 6, was thought at first to "continue" from the first two into 1969 but it now appears likelier that it is from 1967. This lack of connectedness from one paper in a group with another has happened in other batches; it is something to be alert about. See the Analysis below for details on all this.

Other batches in this series are:

(1) Manuscripts ~ Messages Timeline Extraction
(2) Manuscripts ~ Notebooks Timeline Extraction
(4) Manuscripts ~ Reports Timeline Extraction


Dates Event Description and Notes Wiki Notes, Comments
Sheet 1R -- (Probable year 1968) see Analysis below for details
Apr 25 om Delhi, "Vichargoshthi" "Vichargoshthi" translates variously as seminar, symposium, etc
Apr 28 pm Jabalpur - Shahid Smarak Bhawan - Lecture
May 2 - 5 Nargol - Meditation camp Precisely these dates at Nargol are already in Osho Timeline 1968
May 6 pm Bombay- Lecture to Progressive group at Bhartiya Vidhya Bhawan also in Osho Timeline 1968
May 7 am Bombay - Jain Social Group – Lecture at Birla Kreeda Kendra (7th May, 61 he was at Jabalpur as per Notebook Vol 1)
May 15 pm Poona - Spring Lecture series
May 17 am Poona - Lecture at Antarbharti (16th to 23 May 63 he was at Gadarwara, as per Notebook Vol 2)
May 18 - 20 Junagarh - meditation camp
May 20 om Saurashtra - Discussions with Jeevan Jagriti Kendra workers see below
Jun 9 - 11 Udaipur – Meditation camp
Jun 11 om Udaipur - Lecture at Rajasthan teachers' conference Udaipur not explicitly mentioned but inferred
Jun 21 pm Porbandar Rotary Club
Jun 21 - 23 Porbandar - meditation camp
 
Sheet 1V -- clearly continuing from Sheet 1R
Jun 23 om Porbandar, Lecture At Girls boarding school.
Jul 3 - 5 huge Satsang in Bhavnagar
Jul 3 om massive gathering of women in Bhavnagar
Jul 5 om Bhavnagar - Lecture to Teachers and students
Jul 20 - 23 Indore – Knowledge session at Ravindranath Tagore Dance Theatre
Jul 20 om Indore – Discussion with Jeevan Jagriti Kendra workers
(Probably) Jul 21 Indore Discussion with young News Reporters (At press club-Probably) Date and "press club" not mentioned in manuscript
(Probably) Jul 22 Indore Lecture to large gathering of students Date not mentioned in manuscript
Aug 7 pm Gadarwara – Lecture
Aug 8 pm Gadarwara - "Vichargoshthi"
Aug 10 pm Jabalpur - Lecture at Shahid Smarak Bhawan (10th Oct, 30th September also)
(Manuscripts ~ Messages – contains record from 30th Sept to 14th October, It may be this period then it is 1968 or 1969+ if beyond this time or before this time as notebook form was maintained in some period)
 
Sheet 2 -- early 1969? See Analysis below.
Jan 26 Pipariya - Lecture at "people's gathering".
Jan 29 Jabalpur – Lecture at Vishva Maitri Sangh (World friendship organisation)
Feb 2 Jabalpur – Lecture at Technical School
Feb 4 - 6 Shrirampur - "Satsang"

Analysis

About our correspondent's "probably" speculations regarding certain of the facts about Indore, there is no basis for them in the manuscripts, but no harm in accepting them conditionally with a Q-Mark.jpg.

About the talk with JJK workers at or in "Saurashtra" in the afternoon, this is indeed what the transcription says, but there is a jarring note with respect to the Timeline, where this precise time indicates a "normal" camp discourse in Junagarh/Junagadh, Mati Kahai Kumhar Su ~ 03. This is not much of a problem though. Saurashtra is an area of Gujarat which contains Junagarh, and a workers' talk would likely have taken place during the camp, so probably a detail of timing has been scrambled, and either the om for the workers' talk or the om for the Mati Kahai talk should be an am.

About Pipariya, Wikipedia has no less than three of them in Madhya Pradesh. The largest is in Hoshangabad Dist, so it will get the nod.

The main event here concerns nailing the year.

Evidence for 1968 being the year applying to the dates in Sheets 1R and 1V is fairly compelling. First, there is no conflicting info, eg dates when he is in Mumbai in the existing Timeline and in Gadarwara in the above, though of course the absence of conflicting info does not by itself prove anything. It is merely essential, but not conclusive. However, the two matchups, the Nargol camp from May 2 to 5 and the talk in Bhartiya Vidhya Bhawan the next night, are conclusive. There are not going to be two Nargol camps on May 2-5 in different years. There is one quibble with the May 6 event: the date and venue match up but the nature of the audience does not exactly. But there is plenty of wiggle room to not have to worry about that.

It has been observed, especially in Manuscripts ~ Messages Timeline Extraction, that establishing the year for one sheet does not necessarily establish it for the next in any given group. They may be random bits of paper thrown together. Here, let's see ...

First, Sheets 1R and 1V are not randomly thrown together, they are Recto and Verso, flip sides of each other. And the dates and places in 1V are clearly a continuation of those in 1R. A no-brainer.

But Sheet 2 is another matter. It will be more difficult to fit it into the 1969 Timeline, where it was first thought to belong. Reproduced below is the relevant section of that timeline.

date location event
26 Jan 1969 am Anjuman Islamia High School, Jabalpur Naye Bharat Ka Janm ~ 01 ** ( नये भारत का जन्म )
30 Jan 1969 pm Ruia College, Bombay Shanti Ki Khoj (2) ~ 01 ** ( शांति की खोज / The Search for Peace )
31 Jan 1969 am Bombay Naye Bharat Ka Janm ~ 02 ** ( नये भारत का जन्म )
31 Jan 1969 pm Ruia College, Bombay Shanti Ki Khoj (2) ~ 02 ** ( शांति की खोज / The Search for Peace )
1 Feb 1969 Bombay Kya Sove Tu Bavri ~ 01 ** ( क्या सोवे तू बावरी )
1 Feb 1969 pm Ruia College, Bombay Shanti Ki Khoj (2) ~ 03 ** ( शांति की खोज / The Search for Peace )
2 Feb 1969 pm Ruia College, Bombay Shanti Ki Khoj (2) ~ 04 ** ( शांति की खोज / The Search for Peace )

The first potential conflict, on Jan 26, is not difficult. The Timeline event in Jabalpur is in the morning and Pipariya is not prohibitively far, an easy drive. Getting from Jabalpur on Jan 29th to Mumbai on the 30th is also not difficult.

But getting back to Jabalpur for a talk Feb 2 after one the previous evening in Mumbai and then back for another one in Mumbai the evening of the 2nd would be fairly difficult. He would have to fly twice, not a common occurrence in those days but not impossible. But it would also be unlikely anyway, just on the basis of practicality. Why set up a situation like that? Possibly the Feb 2 talk was scheduled but cancelled and/or re-scheduled.

We could also consider other years for these dates. 1968, 1966 and 1965 have prohibitive conflicts (early Feb was a popular time for camps). 1970 has no conflicts and is possible. After that, Osho's travels become much more focused and circumscribed, and not really possible. But 1967 is more than just possible: it has no conflicts, and even turns out to have a positive alignment, albeit with a recently added event from another Manuscripts Timeline Extraction, Feb 4-6 in Shrirampur. The relative lack of independence of these two sources might make their agreement not as impressive as would two independent sources, but even a mini-agreement is attractive in the context of 1969's problems.

1969's one serious conflict could be resolved by Osho flying (twice) or the Jabalpur event cancelled, by no means impossible, but still really too much of a stretch when there is a decent other possibility. So 1967 it is for now.