Talk:Patheya (पाथेय): Difference between revisions

From The Sannyas Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 31: Line 31:
The sections before it all bear titles of translations of English original letter collections. The wiki's collection of Contents pages is incomplete, but what we have ...  
The sections before it all bear titles of translations of English original letter collections. The wiki's collection of Contents pages is incomplete, but what we have ...  
:Contents 2, p 31-63: 2. अन्तर्दर्शन (Antardarshan / ''[[Turning In (letters)|Turning In]]'')
:Contents 2, p 31-63: 2. अन्तर्दर्शन (Antardarshan / ''[[Turning In (letters)|Turning In]]'')
:Contents 3, p 98-133: 4. द्वार-रहित द्वार (Dwar-rahit Dwar / ''[[The Gateless Gate]]'')
:Contents 4, p 98-133: 4. द्वार-रहित द्वार (Dwar-rahit Dwar / ''[[The Gateless Gate]]'')
:Contents 4, p 135-174: 5. आयाम शून्य आयाम (Aayam Shunya Aayam / ''[[The Dimensionless Dimension]]'')
:Contents 5, p 135-174: 5. आयाम शून्य आयाम (Aayam Shunya Aayam / ''[[The Dimensionless Dimension]]'')
:Contents 5, p 175-208: 6. शाश्वत सन्देश (Shashwat Sandesh / ''[[The Eternal Message]]'')
:Contents 6, p 175-208: 6. शाश्वत सन्देश (Shashwat Sandesh / ''[[The Eternal Message]]'')
:Contents 6, p 209-361: भेट वार्ता (written as भेंट-वार्ता in Diamond's TOC, Bhent-Vaarta / interview(s))  
:Contents 7, p 209-361: भेट वार्ता (written as भेंट-वार्ता in Diamond's TOC, Bhent-Vaarta / interview(s))  


Four of the five sections available show titles that are clearly translations of books of letters, and with one title per page, letters is all they can be. The last page, Contents 6, shows the page ranges of the final section (Interviews) as much longer.  
Four of the five sections available show titles that are clearly translations of books of letters, and with one title per page, letters is all they can be. The last page, Contents 6, shows the page ranges of the final section (Interviews) as much longer.  


Evidently there are a couple of missing contents pages, as there are jumps both in the page numbers and in the section title numbers between Contents 2 and Contents 3. We might easily speculate that ''[[The Silent Music]]'' and ''[[What Is Meditation?]]'' are in ''Patheya'' as well.  
Evidently there are a couple of missing contents pages, as there are jumps both in the page numbers and in the section title numbers between Contents 2 and Contents 3**. We might easily speculate that ''[[The Silent Music]]'' and ''[[What Is Meditation?]]'' are in ''Patheya'' as well.  
 
: ** = The paragraph above was written when the Contents pages were numbered differently, 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6. All such numbering has been done by the wiki, not the publisher. Previous commentary had noted only one missing page, the first, now we know there are two. -- doofus-9 04:09, 13 November 2020 (UTC)
So the Diamond book and the Anand Sheela book are quite different, though related. They might merit separate pages. -- doofus-9 22:45, 10 November 2020 (UTC)
So the Diamond book and the Anand Sheela book are quite different, though related. They might merit separate pages. -- doofus-9 22:45, 10 November 2020 (UTC)
----
----

Revision as of 04:09, 13 November 2020

अनुक्रम (TOC)

chapter English source, where known
अनुगूंज : भूमिका preface
:प्रथम भेंट-वार्ता
ध्यान : एक नया आयाम ... 7
Meditation: A New Dimension
दूसरी भेंट-वार्ता
सीमाओं के पार ... 39
तीसरी भेंट-वार्ता
उड़ान अकेले की-अकेले के लिए ... 67
Flight of the Alone to the Alone (interviews)
ध्यान के लिए एक प्रायोगिक तैयारी ... 95
चौथी भेंट-वार्ता
एल एस डी--मिथ्या समाधि का निकट द्वार ... 105
LSD: A Shortcut to False Samadhi
पांचवी भेंट-वार्ता
योग : स्वस्फूर्त घटना ... 129
Yoga As a Spontaneous Happening
छटवी भेंट-वार्ता
जीवंत-संतुलन ... 155
The Vital Balance

A list from Osho Diary 1997 (the image) mentions this title as Letters-compilation. Is that so?--DhyanAntar 07:12, 6 July 2019 (UTC)


The TOC above represents the chapter titles from the Diamond edition of 2014. In fact, those titles DO appear in the 1974 Anand Sheela Prakashan edition too, but they are only a small part of it, snuggled away in the last section of the last Contents page (6), and called "Interviews".

The sections before it all bear titles of translations of English original letter collections. The wiki's collection of Contents pages is incomplete, but what we have ...

Contents 2, p 31-63: 2. अन्तर्दर्शन (Antardarshan / Turning In)
Contents 4, p 98-133: 4. द्वार-रहित द्वार (Dwar-rahit Dwar / The Gateless Gate)
Contents 5, p 135-174: 5. आयाम शून्य आयाम (Aayam Shunya Aayam / The Dimensionless Dimension)
Contents 6, p 175-208: 6. शाश्वत सन्देश (Shashwat Sandesh / The Eternal Message)
Contents 7, p 209-361: भेट वार्ता (written as भेंट-वार्ता in Diamond's TOC, Bhent-Vaarta / interview(s))

Four of the five sections available show titles that are clearly translations of books of letters, and with one title per page, letters is all they can be. The last page, Contents 6, shows the page ranges of the final section (Interviews) as much longer.

Evidently there are a couple of missing contents pages, as there are jumps both in the page numbers and in the section title numbers between Contents 2 and Contents 3**. We might easily speculate that The Silent Music and What Is Meditation? are in Patheya as well.

** = The paragraph above was written when the Contents pages were numbered differently, 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6. All such numbering has been done by the wiki, not the publisher. Previous commentary had noted only one missing page, the first, now we know there are two. -- doofus-9 04:09, 13 November 2020 (UTC)

So the Diamond book and the Anand Sheela book are quite different, though related. They might merit separate pages. -- doofus-9 22:45, 10 November 2020 (UTC)


Diamond publisher is known for publishing small books which are result of separation of previous series. So it is possible we will cross with other published parts from Anand Sheela edition as other(s) Diamond books. Diamond did it with many Kabir series publishing one part under original series name and other part as other book. Wiki in order not doing too much messy, which is enough in Hindi publications, was keeping course to keep different formats of a book with the same title on one (wiki-)book page.--DhyanAntar 03:49, 11 November 2020 (UTC)


Oh, okay, that's very good. -- doofus-9 09:01, 11 November 2020 (UTC)