Talk:Shifting content in Hindi books (source document)

From The Sannyas Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search

These three lines in the table were not in Shailendra's original source doc but added later via email communication:

Prabhu Mandir Ke Dwar Par (प्रभु मंदिर के द्वार पर) 9 ... Cheti Sake To Cheti (चेति सकै तो चेति) 4
Prabhu Mandir Ke Dwar Par (प्रभु मंदिर के द्वार पर) 10 ... not known

(Above two lines concerned the disappearance of these two chapters between an earlier edition and the latest)

Prem Hai Dwar Prabhu Ka (प्रेम है द्वार प्रभु का) 3 (incomplete, first question only) ... Jeevan Darshan (जीवन दर्शन) 2 (complete discourse)
-- doofus-9 07:50, 5 August 2018 (UTC)

Regarding the description of Mera Swarnim Bharat (मेरा स्वर्णिम भारत) as consisting of "various Upanishad sutras - compiled from various discourses", some editions do refer to "various Upanishads" but there seems to be no basis for this. Source discourses for MSB are almost entirely late Pune One Q&A talks, nothing to do with Upanishads. See MSB's discussion page for more on this and a detailed accounting of chapter titles and sources. -- doofus-9 07:47, 11 August 2018 (UTC)


About Paanch Mahaavrat (पांच महाव्रत): This name has appeared on the cover of Jyon Ki Tyon Dhari Dinhi Chadariya (ज्यों की त्यों धरि दीन्हीं चदरिया) as a subtitle for the larger edition which includes the smaller Jyon Ki Tyon and Suli Upar Sej. Perhaps it was intended as an über-title? -- doofus-9 07:47, 11 August 2018 (UTC)


The case of Pad Ghunghru Bandh (पद घुंघरू बांध) (20 talks) is similar to Paanch Mahaavrat in that it has seemed previously to have never been published. Against that, it has been long observed as a popular collective name for the two Meera series. Seeing it here, in this context, perhaps it is time to make it "official"? -- doofus-9 07:30, 12 August 2018 (UTC)


I removed Jeevan Satya Ki Khoj (जीवन सत्य की खोज) #4. There known only 3 talks of this series.

About 4th discourse Shailendra says:

"There are confusions. I don't have physical book. It is not going to be published in future, as 3 discourses are printed in TRISHA GAI EK BUND SE and 4th is printed in ????
(Title of 4th discourse from Shailendra's e-book is) अंतस आलोक की उपलब्धि ? mistake to be corrected- it is not from Chit Chakmat Lage Nahin, #7, But I do not know at present.
o.com and wiki says that 3 talks in this book--I also have only 3 audios."

Also see Talk:Chit Chakmak Lage Nahin (चित चकमक लागै नहीं) for info on 7th talk.--DhyanAntar 15:35, 17 September 2018 (UTC)

No track for 8th talk of Chit Chakmak Lage Nahin (चित चकमक लागै नहीं). This series has only 6 audios.

But 7th and 8th appeared in Moulik Kranti (मौलिक क्रान्ति) as ch.7-8 of part I, which titled Chit Chakmak Lage Nahin. Relation with real Chit is unlikely.--DhyanAntar 05:48, 26 April 2020 (UTC)

This chapter published now in one of editions of Trisha, see Talk:Trisha Gai Ek Boond Se (तृषा गई एक बूंद से).--DhyanAntar 16:47, 8 May 2020 (UTC)


Jeevan Ki Kala (जीवन की कला) #11-13 are the same as Jeevan Ki Kala #8-10. Oshoganga has these 13 ch-version-edition. And Shailendra PDF has 10 chapter edition. Complete table of comparing is available here: Talk:Jeevan Ki Kala (जीवन की कला).--DhyanAntar 13:19, 25 April 2020 (UTC)

Jeevan Ki Khoj (जीवन की खोज) (old ed) 9 = Jeevan Ki Kala (जीवन की कला) 6 : 6th corrected into "1" according new checked table with comparing on Talk:Jeevan Ki Kala (जीवन की कला) page.--DhyanAntar 10:49, 11 May 2020 (UTC)


Jeevan Rahasya (जीवन रहस्य) 7 = Sambodhi Ke Kshan (सम्बोधि के क्षण) 7. It is true. But their equality to Nanak Dukhiya Sab Sansar (नानक दुखिया सब संसार) is wrong. Nanak is a part of Dukh Ke Paar (दुख के पार), which has Jeevan Rahasya 's chapter, but it is not among Nanak 's chapters. As no exact chapter number mentioned in the source document, it is other suspicious.--DhyanAntar 03:56, 2 October 2020 (UTC)