Audio Quality: Difference between revisions

From The Sannyas Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(correct info)
(add info)
Line 3: Line 3:


:We think that the quality of Osho's discourses is very important, as it not only conveys the words, but the whole atmosphere of the words and the silences, the birds, the trains and the wind in the leaves. In optima forma listening to the audio should be as if you are sitting right there in Osho's presence.
:We think that the quality of Osho's discourses is very important, as it not only conveys the words, but the whole atmosphere of the words and the silences, the birds, the trains and the wind in the leaves. In optima forma listening to the audio should be as if you are sitting right there in Osho's presence.
:But when one listens to audio of the latest "editions" (see [[Recording Osho's discourses on audio and video#Editions and versions|Editions and versions]]) i.e. with the latest quality editing, the sound leaves a lot to be desired. Strange! We feel this is a matter for concern.


:But when one listens to audio of the latest "editions" (see [[Recording Osho's discourses on audio and video#Editions and versions|Editions and versions]]) i.e. with the latest quality editing, the sound leaves a lot to be desired. Strange, because we would expect the very best quality! We feel this is a matter for concern.
:On this page we present some samples of audio editions, so you can hear for yourself. You don't need audiophile equipment to hear the differences, just maybe a good headphone.
:What we hear is that even edition 3 with the latest audio techniques available sounds very mediocre. And edition 1 is surprisingly good.
:By the way, edition 2 audio, made on the basis of the quality editing in the early nineties and available from OshoWorld.com, sounds even worse than edition 3.


:On this page we present some samples of audio editions, so you can hear for yourself. You don't need audiophile equipment to hear the differences.
:What we hear is that edition 2 is really bad, edition 3 is a little better, but still very mediocre. And edition 1 is surprisingly good.
:If you know anything about this issue, please write to us: '''help[[image:666.gif|link=]]sannyas.wiki'''.  
:If you know anything about this issue, please write to us: '''help[[image:666.gif|link=]]sannyas.wiki'''.  


{| class="wikitable" style="margin:auto"
{| class="wikitable" style="margin:auto"
|-
|-
!! edition 2 !! edition 3 !! edition 1
!  !! edition 3 !! edition 1
|-
|-
|  || It was made on the basis of the quality editing in the early nineties, they can be recognized by the voice of Amrito as intro, without music.<br>This version has been downloaded from oshoworld.com. The quality is pretty bad, but that might have been caused by later changes, like more mp3-compression.|| This audio was aquired at osho.com, with a next level of quality editing, made in the early 2000s. It can be recognized by the muzak around the intro. Indeed, the quality is better than e2, but actually not quite good: too much cleaning of noise gives a 'sterile' sound.
|   
|| This audio was digitized from a collection of '''tape-cassettes''' produced in the seventies. They van be recognized by the original intro.  They were aquired from the Osho Meditation Centre at the Cornelis Troostplein, Amsterdam, where they were used as master-tapes until the early nineties. '''(*1)'''  
| Edition 3 audio was aquired at osho.com, with --one would expect-- the highest level of quality editing, probably made in the early 2000s. Indeed, the quality is better than e2, but actually not quite good: too much cleaning of noise has given a 'sterile' sound, missing high frequencies.
| Our sample Edition 1 audio was digitized from '''tape-cassettes''' produced in the seventies. They were aquired from the Osho Meditation Centre at the Cornelis Troostplein, Amsterdam, where they were used as master-tapes until the early nineties. '''(*1)'''  
|-
|-
| [[Tao The Three Treasures Vol 3 ~ 01]] || [[file:Tao The Three Treasures Vol 3 -01 e2.mp3]] || [[file:Tao The Three Treasures Vol 3 -01_e3 (first part).mp3]] || [[file:Tao The Three Treasures Vol 3 -01_e1 (first part, 44.1kHz 320kbps).mp3]]
| [[Tao The Three Treasures Vol 3 ~ 01]] || [[file:Tao The Three Treasures Vol 3 -01_e3 (first part).mp3]] || [[file:Tao The Three Treasures Vol 3 -01_e1 (first part, 44.1kHz 320kbps).mp3]]
|-
|-
| Example || Example || Example || Example
| Example || Example || Example  
|-
|-
| Example || Example || Example || Example
| Example || Example || Example  
|-
|-
| Example || Example || Example || Example
| Example || Example || Example  
  |}
  |}
:(*1) The audio-cassettes have been digitized by a friend. Procedure:
:::<small>Tapes played real-time on a '''Nakamichi RX-202E''', <br>it's signal output to a analog to digital converter '''RDL HR-ADC1''',<br>output to a USB-to-digital interface '''Mutec MC-1.2'''<br>interfacing to a PC with software '''Wavelab Elements''' to produce WAV files.
:::These were then checked for completenes, audio levels maximized and saved as FLAC 16bit mono in software '''Goldwave'''.
:::For display here the FLAC was converted to MP3 as 44.1kHz, 320kbps.</small>
:: <gallery widths=400px heights=400px mode="packed">  
:: <gallery widths=400px heights=400px mode="packed">  
image:Shanta's box DSC_1551.JPG| The sort of cassettes used in edition 1.
image:Shanta's box DSC_1551.JPG| The sort of cassettes used in edition 1.
Image:Shanta's tape DSC_1554.JPG| The sort of cassettes used in edition 1.
Image:Shanta's tape DSC_1554.JPG| The sort of cassettes used in edition 1.
</gallery>
</gallery>
(*1) The audio-cassettes have been digitized by a friend. Procedure:
::<small>Tapes played real-time on a '''Nakamichi RX-202E''', <br>it's signal output to a analog to digital converter '''RDL HR-ADC1''',<br>output to a USB-to-digital interface '''Mutec MC-1.2'''<br>interfacing to a PC with software '''Wavelab Elements''' to produce WAV files.
::These were then checked for completenes, audio levels maximized and saved as FLAC 16bit mono in software '''Goldwave'''.
::For display here the FLAC was converted to MP3 as 44.1kHz, 320kbps.</small>





Revision as of 09:41, 26 June 2022

 This page is under construction.  
Recording of Osho talking has been done with great care. Of course in the early days that happened with primitive means, and as time went on with superb equipment.
We think that the quality of Osho's discourses is very important, as it not only conveys the words, but the whole atmosphere of the words and the silences, the birds, the trains and the wind in the leaves. In optima forma listening to the audio should be as if you are sitting right there in Osho's presence.
But when one listens to audio of the latest "editions" (see Editions and versions) i.e. with the latest quality editing, the sound leaves a lot to be desired. Strange, because we would expect the very best quality! We feel this is a matter for concern.


On this page we present some samples of audio editions, so you can hear for yourself. You don't need audiophile equipment to hear the differences, just maybe a good headphone.
What we hear is that even edition 3 with the latest audio techniques available sounds very mediocre. And edition 1 is surprisingly good.
By the way, edition 2 audio, made on the basis of the quality editing in the early nineties and available from OshoWorld.com, sounds even worse than edition 3.
If you know anything about this issue, please write to us: helpsannyas.wiki.
edition 3 edition 1
Edition 3 audio was aquired at osho.com, with --one would expect-- the highest level of quality editing, probably made in the early 2000s. Indeed, the quality is better than e2, but actually not quite good: too much cleaning of noise has given a 'sterile' sound, missing high frequencies. Our sample Edition 1 audio was digitized from tape-cassettes produced in the seventies. They were aquired from the Osho Meditation Centre at the Cornelis Troostplein, Amsterdam, where they were used as master-tapes until the early nineties. (*1)
Tao The Three Treasures Vol 3 ~ 01
Example Example Example
Example Example Example
Example Example Example
  • The sort of cassettes used in edition 1.

    The sort of cassettes used in edition 1.

  • The sort of cassettes used in edition 1.

    The sort of cassettes used in edition 1.

  • (*1) The audio-cassettes have been digitized by a friend. Procedure:

    Tapes played real-time on a Nakamichi RX-202E,
    it's signal output to a analog to digital converter RDL HR-ADC1,
    output to a USB-to-digital interface Mutec MC-1.2
    interfacing to a PC with software Wavelab Elements to produce WAV files.
    These were then checked for completenes, audio levels maximized and saved as FLAC 16bit mono in software Goldwave.
    For display here the FLAC was converted to MP3 as 44.1kHz, 320kbps.


    see also
    Recording Osho's discourses on audio and video