Talk:Kasturi Kundal Basai (कस्तूरी कुंडल बसै): Difference between revisions
(Created page with "A curious quirk led to the addition of this TOC for ''Kasturi''. Both the seventh and tenth discourses are featured as chapters in a small Kabir compilation, ''Ghoonghat Ke...") |
Dhyanantar (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
| (5 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
A curious quirk led to the addition of this TOC for ''Kasturi''. Both the seventh and tenth discourses are featured as chapters in a small Kabir compilation, ''[[Ghoonghat Ke Pat Khol (घूंघट के पट खोल)]]''. But the seventh was not detected at first because another talk with that same title was found first, talk #4 of ''[[Kahai Kabir Diwana (कहै कबीर दीवाना)]]''. | A curious quirk led to the addition of this TOC for ''Kasturi''. Both the seventh and tenth discourses are featured as chapters in a small Kabir compilation, ''[[Ghoonghat Ke Pat Khol (घूंघट के पट खोल) (compilation)]]''. But the seventh was not detected at first because another talk with that same title was found first, talk #4 of ''[[Kahai Kabir Diwana (कहै कबीर दीवाना)]]''. | ||
We are informed by [[Sw Shailendra Saraswati|Shailendra]] that the | We are informed by [[Sw Shailendra Saraswati|Shailendra]] that the title in ''Kahai Kabir'' is natural and correct, as it is the first line of the song, while the one in ''Kasturi'' is an editor's mistake. But for all that, the one in Kasturi is the one in ''Ghoonghat'', so that's that. -- doofus-9 04:04, 12 July 2017 (UTC) | ||
Kasturi TOC: | Kasturi TOC: | ||
:1. | :1. अंतर्यात्रा के मूल सूत्र | ||
:2. धर्म कला | :2. धर्म कला है--मृत्यु की, अमृत की | ||
:3. मन के जाल हजार | :3. मन के जाल हजार | ||
:4. विराम है द्वार राम का | :4. विराम है द्वार राम का | ||
:5. धर्म और | :5. धर्म और संप्रदाय में भेद | ||
:6. अभीप्सा की आगः अमृत की वर्षा | :6. अभीप्सा की आगः अमृत की वर्षा | ||
:7. मन रे जागत | :7. मन रे जागत रहिये भाई | ||
:8. शिष्यत्व महान क्रांति है | :8. शिष्यत्व महान क्रांति है | ||
:9. प्रार्थना है उत्सव | :9. प्रार्थना है उत्सव | ||
:10. उपलब्धि के अंतिम चरण | :10. उपलब्धि के अंतिम चरण | ||
---- | |||
The OIF copyright claim dating "1977, 2012" has led to two assumptions/inferences: 1) that Diamond's edition was published in 2012 (that is not evident in the pub-info page) and 2) that there was an RF edition in 1977. -- doofus-9 07:21, 15 August 2017 (UTC) | |||
[[image:Kasturi Kundal Basai Jagdish dates.jpg|right|400px]] | |||
Latest revision as of 17:43, 18 May 2020
A curious quirk led to the addition of this TOC for Kasturi. Both the seventh and tenth discourses are featured as chapters in a small Kabir compilation, Ghoonghat Ke Pat Khol (घूंघट के पट खोल) (compilation). But the seventh was not detected at first because another talk with that same title was found first, talk #4 of Kahai Kabir Diwana (कहै कबीर दीवाना).
We are informed by Shailendra that the title in Kahai Kabir is natural and correct, as it is the first line of the song, while the one in Kasturi is an editor's mistake. But for all that, the one in Kasturi is the one in Ghoonghat, so that's that. -- doofus-9 04:04, 12 July 2017 (UTC)
Kasturi TOC:
- 1. अंतर्यात्रा के मूल सूत्र
- 2. धर्म कला है--मृत्यु की, अमृत की
- 3. मन के जाल हजार
- 4. विराम है द्वार राम का
- 5. धर्म और संप्रदाय में भेद
- 6. अभीप्सा की आगः अमृत की वर्षा
- 7. मन रे जागत रहिये भाई
- 8. शिष्यत्व महान क्रांति है
- 9. प्रार्थना है उत्सव
- 10. उपलब्धि के अंतिम चरण
The OIF copyright claim dating "1977, 2012" has led to two assumptions/inferences: 1) that Diamond's edition was published in 2012 (that is not evident in the pub-info page) and 2) that there was an RF edition in 1977. -- doofus-9 07:21, 15 August 2017 (UTC)
