Talk:Dadu Sahajai Dekhiye (दादू सहजै देखिये): Difference between revisions

From The Sannyas Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page with "It is not explicitly stated in the pages we have images for but indications are strong that the source for this book is the second half of ''Piv Piv Lagi Pyas (पिव प...")
 
No edit summary
 
(3 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
It is not explicitly stated in the pages we have images for but indications are strong that the source for this book is the second half of ''[[Piv Piv Lagi Pyas (पिव पिव लागी प्यास)|Piv Piv]]''.
It is not explicitly stated in the pages we have images for but indications are strong that the source for this book is the second half of ''[[Piv Piv Laagi Pyas (पिव पिव लागी प्यास)|Piv Piv]]''.


The book is clearly about Dadu. Both the title and subtitle, दादू वाणी (the voice or songs of Dadu) confirm this. Looking through the chapter titles of Osho's two books on Dadu, we find that only two of Diamond's titles match up with any of them, #2 and 4 matching # 7 and 9 of ''Piv Piv'', those being the 2nd and 4th chapters in the second half of ''Piv Piv''. And Diamond does a lot of "half"-books, dividing ten-chapter books into two five-chapter books.  
The book is clearly about Dadu. Both the title and subtitle, दादू वाणी (the voice or songs of Dadu) confirm this. Looking through the chapter titles of Osho's two books on Dadu, we find that only two of Diamond's titles match up with any of them, #2 and 4 matching # 7 and 9 of ''Piv Piv'', those being the 2nd and 4th chapters in the second half of ''Piv Piv''. And Diamond does a lot of "half"-books, dividing ten-chapter books into two five-chapter books.  
Line 13: Line 13:
:2. ल्यौ लागी तब जाणिए . . . . .36
:2. ल्यौ लागी तब जाणिए . . . . .36
:3. अपने भीतर खोजो . . . . . . . 60
:3. अपने भीतर खोजो . . . . . . . 60
:4. मन चित चातक ज्यूं रटै . . . .88
:4. मन चित्त चातक ज्यूं रटै . . . .88
:5. प्रेम : मुक्त आकाश . . . . . .116
:5. प्रेम : मुक्त आकाश . . . . . .116
|
|
Line 22: Line 22:
:10: जिज्ञासा-पूर्ति: पांच  
:10: जिज्ञासा-पूर्ति: पांच  
|}
|}
----
Title page of this book states clearly that previously published as ch.6-10 of ''Piv Piv''.--DhyanAntar 11:57, 27 November 2018 (UTC)

Latest revision as of 06:32, 15 January 2021

It is not explicitly stated in the pages we have images for but indications are strong that the source for this book is the second half of Piv Piv.

The book is clearly about Dadu. Both the title and subtitle, दादू वाणी (the voice or songs of Dadu) confirm this. Looking through the chapter titles of Osho's two books on Dadu, we find that only two of Diamond's titles match up with any of them, #2 and 4 matching # 7 and 9 of Piv Piv, those being the 2nd and 4th chapters in the second half of Piv Piv. And Diamond does a lot of "half"-books, dividing ten-chapter books into two five-chapter books.

This is suggestive. A glance at Piv Piv's non-matching titles reveals the rest of the correspondence in a classic lightbulb moment. Those three titles are almost all the same as each other, translating as "curiosity fulfillment: three", "curiosity fulfillment: four" and "curiosity fulfillment: five". Essentially they are un-titled Q&A chapters in Piv Piv, and they have just been given "real" titles in Diamond's version. -- doofus-9 04:03, 20 June 2017 (UTC)

Diamond Piv Piv
1. जन्म, मृत्यु और प्रेम . . . . . . .7
2. ल्यौ लागी तब जाणिए . . . . .36
3. अपने भीतर खोजो . . . . . . . 60
4. मन चित्त चातक ज्यूं रटै . . . .88
5. प्रेम : मुक्त आकाश . . . . . .116
6: जिज्ञासा-पूर्ति: तीन
7: ल्यौ लागी तब जाणिए
8: जिज्ञासा-पूर्ति: चार
9: मन चित चातक ज्यूं रटै
10: जिज्ञासा-पूर्ति: पांच

Title page of this book states clearly that previously published as ch.6-10 of Piv Piv.--DhyanAntar 11:57, 27 November 2018 (UTC)