Talk:Jin-Sutra, Bhag 1 (जिन-सूत्र, भाग एक) (2 volume set)

From The Sannyas Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Lots of ambiguities attending publication of this series and its companion Vol 2, and it's not like they are long-lost early talks.

The Divyansh edition purports to be a double volume, 950 pages, ostensibly including both Vol 1 and Vol 2, but the cover images available only show Vol 1. Its ISBN is findable but not by all searchers.

There is info on the net supporting belief in an English translation of Vol 1, by Osho Media International no less, with the following factoids: ISBN 9788172612764, 8172612761, pub date 2013, H and 492pp. But its ISBN is not findable, nor (while we're here) is the old Rebel ISBN 81-7261-181-1. (And never mind the Rajneesh Foundation edition.) -- Sarlo (talk) 08:28, 15 February 2014 (PST)


Also redirected "Zin Sutra Vol 1" here, which can only be a mis-transliteration, same discourse dates, etc. Its cover image (2686 sml.jpg) is very similar to the Rebel cover image but not identical. It IS of higher res and may be useful. -- 09:00, 15 February 2014 (PST)


A small detail of the production credits in the pub info needs a question mark: Pretty much the same crew is there year after year in many of these books, so an apparently new name which is only slightly different raises eyebrows. Thus we have one of the typists here (and in Jin Sutra Bhag 2 for that matter), a "Ma Anand Bhagwati" ... This may be a mistake, as there is a perennial typist in many other books called "Ma Prem Bhagwati".

We might also wonder about the "Sw Anand Prabhu" who is here after Bhagwati in the typing pool, especially when the perennial -- though not as a typist -- Sw Prem Prabhbu is credited in the same publication. (Coming right after Bhagwati, a second Prem-->Anand substitution?) -- doofus-9 09:08, 29 January 2018 (UTC)


ISBN 9788172612764 belongs to Jin-Sutra, Bhag 1 (जिन-सूत्र, भाग एक) (4 volume set), first vol of 4 vol-edition published OMI.--DhyanAntar 08:46, 19 October 2018 (UTC)