Doc X (source document): Difference between revisions
Dhyanantar (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
Dhyanantar (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
Line 378: | Line 378: | ||
| SAHAJ YOG || 10 || TILOPA || DEC 01-20 1978 | | SAHAJ YOG || 10 || TILOPA || DEC 01-20 1978 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| SAHIB MIL SAHIB BHAYE || 05 || QUEST & ANS || JUL 11-20 1980 || Pune One, agrees | | SAHIB MIL SAHIB BHAYE || 05 || QUEST & ANS || JUL 11-20 1980 || Pune One, agrees, except 10 talks | ||
|- | |- | ||
| SAMADHI KAMAL* || 15 || YOG/DHY/SADH || || | | SAMADHI KAMAL* || 15 || YOG/DHY/SADH || || |
Revision as of 06:09, 5 June 2020
"Doc X" is a source of information about Osho's Hindi discourses much used by Sannyas Wiki. It came into use as a significant outside source largely before Neeten's Osho Source Book and after Gyan Bhed. Its author is unknown. A contact email on a similar document yielded no responses. It offers info on as many of Osho's Hindi series as it could get together at the time, that time also unknown. As of Aug 2015 it still could be found as a Yahoo groups file, though it is not known with what group it is connected. Its original format of MS Word has been converted to wikitables here. Spelling of titles and ALL CAPS lettering have been retained in their original form, as have all the data, excepting a few abbreviations. A column of notes not in the original has been added on the right relating to how data fit with existing data. Some of these notes have become obsolete. Some "meta-notes" are included after the table discussing the statistical reliability of the whole set.
- There are 200 titles, 138 of them with dates
- ** = (of undated series, those with audio; note this designation is not in original)
- Asterisks (*) beside some titles as per the original, their significance unknown
- Unfamiliar subjects include names of Indian poets and mystics,
- "YOG/DHY/SADH" = yoga / dhyan / sadhana, basically talks about meditation and practice
- In "Notes", "agrees" refers to previous wiki data,and "Camps" to Meditation Camps.
TITLES | # OF DISC |
SUBJECT | DATES AND PLACES | NOTES (nb added by wiki, not part of original) |
ADHYATMA UPANISHAD* | 17 | UPANISHAD | OCT 13-21 1971. MOUNT ABU | wrong year, should be 1972 |
AGHYAT KI OR* | 07 | QUEST & ANS | ** | found pdf with #4 - Surat, Jun 29, 1967 and one more ch Jun 30/67 |
AJAHOON CHET GANWAR | 21 | PALTUDAS | JUL 21 - AUG 10 1977 | Pune One, agrees |
AMI JHARAT BIGSAT KANWAL | 14 | DARIYADAS | MAR 11 -24 1979 | Pune One, agrees |
AMRIT KI DISHA* | 08 | QUEST & ANS | ** | |
AMRIT DWAR* | 06 | QUEST & ANS | ** | turns out to be (per e-book) scattered Q&As @ Bombay, Pune and possibly Baroda |
AMRIT VARSHA | 05 | QUEST & ANS | ** | |
ANANT KI PUKAR | 12 | QUEST & ANS | ||
ANHAD MEIN BISRAM | 10 | QUEST & ANS | NOV 11-20 1980 | Pune One, agrees |
ANTAR KI KHOJ* | 10 | QUEST & ANS | ** | |
APNE MAANHI TATOL* | 08 | YOG/DHY/SADH | ** | |
APUI GAYI HIRAI | 10 | QUEST & ANS | FEB 01-10 1981 | Pune One, agrees |
ARI MAIN TO NAM KE RANG CHHAKI | 10 | JAGJIVANDAS | SEP 11-20 1978 | Pune One, agrees |
ASAMBHAV KRANTI* | 10 | YOG/DHY/SADH | OCT 18-21 1967. MATHERAN | previously unlisted in "Camps" |
ATHATO BHAKTI JIGYASA VOL 1 | 20 | SHANDILYA | JAN 11-30 1978 | Pune One, agrees, except Jan 11-31. But in fact, Jan 30 is what it should be, according to audio count of this and Jas Panihar, the following series. |
ATAHTO BHAKTI JIGYASA VOL 2 | 20 | SHANDILYA | MAR 11-30 1978 | Pune One, agrees |
BAHURI NA AISA DAON | 10 | QUEST & ANS | AUG 01-10 1980 | Pune One, agrees |
BAHUTERE HAIN GHAAT | 04 | QUEST & ANS | MAR 21-24 1981 | Pune One, agrees |
BHAJ GOVINDAM | 10 | ADI SHANKRA | NOV 11-20 1975 | Pune One, agrees |
BHARAT KA BHAVISHYA | 12 | POLI & SOC | JAN 21 1968. BOMBAY | not previously dated |
BHAKTI SUTRA VOL 1 | 10 | NARAD | JAN 11-20 1976 | Pune One, agrees |
BHAKTI SUTRA VOL 2 | 10 | NARAD | MAR 11-22 1976 | Pune One, agrees, except Mar 11-20 |
BIN BAATI BIN TEL | 19 | ZEN/SUFI STORIES | JUN 29 - JUL 09 1974 | Pune One, agrees, except Jun 21 - Jul 9 |
BIN GHAN PARAT FUHAAR | 10 | SAHAJOBAI | OCT 01-10 1975 | Pune One, agrees |
BIRHINI MANDIR DIYA NA BAAR | 10 | YARI | JAN 11-20 1979 | Pune One, agrees |
CHETI SAKE TO CHET* | 06 | YOG/DHY/SADH | ** | |
CHIT CHAKMAK LAGE NAHI* | 06 | QUEST & ANS | ** | |
DARIYA KAHE SHABD NIRVANA | 09 | DARIYADAS | JAN 21-30 1979 | Pune One, agrees, except Jan 21-31 |
DEEPAK BARA NAAM KA | 10 | QUEST & ANS | OCT 01-10 1980 | Pune One, agrees |
DEKH KABIRA ROYA | 30 | POLI & SOC | DEC 2-3 1968. BOMBAY | not previously dated. Other sources confirm 30 talks in a 3-vol set, with DKR both the set name and 3rd vol, but hardly fitting into just these two days |
DHARM AUR ANAND | 09 | QUEST & ANS | ** | |
DHARM KI KHOJ | 01 | YOG/DHY/SADH | JUL 24 1965. BHAVNAGAR | previously unlisted in "Camps," in fact this "book" also previously unlisted |
DHARM KI YATRA | 10 | QUEST & ANS | ** | |
DHARM SADHANA KE SUTRA* | 10 | YOG/DHY/SADH | JUN 20 1965. BOMBAY | not previously dated |
DHYAN DARSHAN* | 10 | YOG/DHY/SADH | ** | |
DHYAN KE KAMAL* | 10 | YOG/DHY/SADH | ** | |
DHYAN SUTRA* | 09 | MEDITATION | FEB 12-15 1965. MAHABLESHWAR | Agrees with "Camps" except Feb 14 |
DIYA TALE ANDHERA | 20 | ZEN/SUFI STORIES | SEP 21 - OCT 10 1974 | Pune One, agrees |
EK EK KADAM* | 07 | YOG/DHY/SADH | ** | |
EK NAYA DWAR | 05 | QUEST & ANS | ** | |
EK OMKAR SATNAM | 20 | GURUNANAK | NOV 21 - DEC 10 1974 | Pune One, agrees |
ES DHAMMO SANANTANO VOL 1 | 20 | BUDDHA | NOV 21 - DEC 10 1975 | Pune One, agrees |
ES DHAMMO SANANTANO VOL 2 | 24 | BUDDHA | JAN 21 - FEB 10 1976 | Pune One, dates agree but 21 talks |
ES DHAMMO SANANTANO VOL 3 | 19 | BUDDHA | MAR 23 - APR 10 1976 | Pune One, agrees |
ES DHAMMO SANANTANO VOL 4 | 21 | BUDDHA | MAR 21 - APR 10 1977 | Pune One, agrees |
ES DHAMMO SANANTANO VOL 5 | 21 | BUDDHA | MAY 21 - JUN 10 1977 | Pune One, agrees |
ES DHAMMO SANANTANO VOL 6 | 20 | BUDDHA | NOV 21 - DEC 10 1977 | Pune One, agrees |
GEETA DARSHAN VOL 1-2 | 18 | BHAG'D GEETA | NOV 29 - DEC 07 1970.AHMEDABAD | previously unlisted in "Camps" |
GEETA DARSHAN VOL 3 | 10 | BHAG'D GEETA | DEC 28 - JAN 06 1970. BOMBAY | Great uncertainty existed for all but the last two Geeta Darshan volumes, not even how many volumes known. Also not known if Pune and Ahmedabad events are camps or other, mainly speaking events. See Geeta-Darshan's talk page for full exploration of sources and issues. |
GEETA DARSHAN VOL 4 | 18 | BHAG'D GEETA | JAN 30 - FEB 07 1971. PUNE | |
GEETA DARSHAN VOL 5 | 11 | BHAG'D GEETA | MAR 13-23 1971. BOMBAY | |
GEETA DARSHAN VOL 6 | 11 | BHAG'D GEETA | MAY 02-12 1971 | |
GEETA DARSHAN VOL 7 | 10 | BHAG'D GEETA | MAY 22-31 1971 | |
GEETA DARSHAN VOL 8 | 7 | BHAG'D GEETA | NOV 25 - DEC 01. PUNE | presumed 1971 and as above |
GEETA DARSHAN VOL 9 | BHAG'D GEETA | MAR 03-15 1972. BOMBAY | as above | |
GEETA DARSHAN VOL 10 | 15 | BHAG'D GEETA | MAY 06-20 1972. BOMBAY | as above |
GEETA DARSHAN VOL 11 | 12 | BHAG'D GEETA | JAN 03-14 1973 | as above |
GEETA DARSHAN VOL 12 | 10 | BHAG'D GEETA | MAR 13-22 1973 | as above |
GEETA DARSHAN VOL 13 | 10 | BHAG'D GEETA | MAY 04-13 1973. BOMBAY | as above |
GEETA DARSHAN VOL 14 | 10 | BHAG'D GEETA | DEC 01-10 1973. BOMBAY | as above |
GEETA DARSHAN VOL 15 | 7 | BHAG'D GEETA | MAY 05-11 1974. BOMBAY | Assuming "May" here a typo for "Mar", everything falls into place. Vol 16 in Pune, rest as above |
GEETA DARSHAN VOL 16 | 8 | BHAG'D GEETA | MAR 30-APR 06 1974 | |
GEETA DARSHAN VOL 17 | 11 | BHAG'D GEETA | MAY 21-31 1975 | Pune One, agrees |
GEETA DARSHAN VOL 18 | 21 | BHAG'D GEETA | JUL 21 - AUG 10 1975 | Pune One, agrees |
GEHRE PANI PETH | 05 | QUEST & ANS | ** | Gahre Pani Paith has 4 or 6 ch, lots of messy crossover with Main Kahta Aankhan Dekhi and other books, see GPP's talk page. |
GURU PARTAP SAADH KI SANGAT | 11 | BHIKHA | MAY 21-31 1979 | Pune One, agrees |
HANSA TO MOTI CHUGE | 10 | LAL | MAY 11-20 1979 | Pune One, agrees |
HARI BOL HARI BOL | 10 | SUNDERDAS | JUN 01-10 1978 | Pune One, agrees |
HASIBA KHELIBA DHARIBA DHYANAM | 03 | YOG/DHY/SADH | ** | |
ISHAVAASYA UPANISHAD* | 13 | UPANISHAD | APR 04-10 1971. MOUNT ABU | Agrees with "Camps" |
JAGAT TARIAYA BHOR KI | 10 | DAYABAI | MAR 11-MAR 20 1977 | Pune One, agrees |
JAS PANIHAR DHARE SIR GAAGAR | 11 | DHARAMDAS | JAN 30 - FEB 10 1978 | Pune One, agrees, except Feb 1-10. This one right basically, though audio count would make it Jan 31, not 30 as here. See also Athato Bhakti Jigyasa Vol 1. |
JHARAT DASAHUN DIS MOTI | 21 | GULAL | JAN 21 - FEB 10 1980 | Pune One, agrees |
JIN KHOJA TIN PAAYA* | 19 | MEDITATION | MAY 2-05 1970, JUN 15, JUL 1-12 1970 NARGOL, BOMBAY | Agrees with "Camps" re Nargol dates |
JIN SUTRA VOL 1 | 31 | MAHAVIR | MAY 11 - JUN 10 1976 | Pune One, agrees |
JIN SUTRA VOL 2 | 31 | MAHAVIR | JUL 11 - AUG 10 1976 | Pune One, agrees |
JIVAN DARSHAN* | 07 | QUEST & ANS | ** | |
JIVAN HI HAI PRABHU | 07 | MEDITATION | DEC9-12 1969. JUNAGADH | agrees with "Camps," in fact improves on it, since dates previously Dec ?-? |
JIVAN KI KHOJ* | 09 | QUEST & ANS | ** | |
JIVAN KRANTI KE SUTRA* | 10 | QUEST & ANS | JUN 2 1969 | Previously unlisted. May be a part of a camp, has multiple issues explored in Talk page. Not to be confused with another JKKS written by Osho's brother Shailendra, now also a guru figure. |
JIVAN RAHASYA* | 13 | QUEST & ANS | ** | |
JIVAN SANGEET* | 09 | YOG/DHY/SADH | ** | other sources have 10 disc |
JO BOLE TO HARIKATHA | 11 | QUEST & ANS | JUL 21-31 1980 | Pune One, agrees |
JO GHAR BAARE AAPNA* | 08 | YOG/DHY/SADH | ** | |
JYOTI SE JYOTI JALE | 21 | SUNDERDAS | JUL 11-31 1978 | Pune One, agrees |
JYOTISH: ADWAIT KA VIGYAAN. ARTHAT ADHYATMA | 02 | JYOTISH | JUL 09-10 1971. BOMBAY | Title here a melange of two titles on Jyotish (Indian astrology) possibly published separately. Both also tangled up with Main Kahta Aankhan Dekhi and Gahre Pani Paith. See Talk pages for each. |
JYUN KI TYUN DHAR DINI CHADARIYA | 13 | MEDITATION | SEPT 01-05 1970. BOMBAY | Has date issues when compared with other sources, see Jyon Ki Tyon's Talk page. |
JYUN MACHHLI BIN NEER | 10 | QUEST & ANS | SEP 21-30 1980 | Pune One, agrees |
JYUN THA TYUN THAHARAYA | 10 | QUEST & ANS | SEP 11-20 1980 | Pune One, agrees |
KA KAHUN US DESKI* | 02 | QUES & ANS | ||
KA SOVAI DIN RAIN | 11 | DHARAMDAS | MAR 31 - APR 10 1978 | Pune One, agrees |
KA SOVAI TU BAAVRI | 04 | QUEST & ANS | ||
KAANO SUNI SO JHOOTH SAB | 10 | DARIYADAS | JUL 11-20 1977 | Pune One, agrees |
KAHE HOT ADHEER | 19 | PALTUDAS | SEP 11-30 1979 | Pune One, agrees |
KAHE KABIR DIWANA | 20 | KABIR | GKS JAN 11-20 1975. MMKN JUN 01-10 1975 |
GKS = Gunge Keri Sarkar and MMKN = Mera Mujhmein Kuchh Nahin, both Pune One, dates agree but other sources have KKD a collective title for MMKN and itself, not GKS, and KKMPP a collective title for GKS and itself. |
KAHE KABIR MAIN PURA PAAYA | 20 | KABIR | ||
KAHE WAJID PUKAAR | 10 | WAJID | SEP 21-30 1978 | Pune One, agrees |
KAIVALYA UPANISHAD* | 17 | UPANISHAD | MAR 25 - APR 02 1972. MOUNT ABU | Agrees with "Camps" |
KAN THORE KANKAR GHANE | 10 | MALUKDAS | MAY 11-20 1977 | Pune One, agrees |
KARM AUR DHYAN | 01 | YOG/DHY/SADH | MAR 20 1966. AHMEDABAD | previously unlisted in "Camps" and as a book title but Neeten does list it at that date in Ahmedabad. |
KARUNA AUR KRANTI* | 06 | QUEST & ANS | ||
KATHOPANISHAD* | 17 | UPANISHAD | OCT 06-13 1973. MOUNT ABU | previously unlisted in "Camps", may actually end Oct 14 counting discourses |
KOPLEIN PHIR PHOOT AAYI | 17 | QUEST & ANS | JUL 31 - AUG 09 1986. BOMBAY | One of the three Hindi World Tour series, all difficult to confirm, KPPA data partly helpful in conjunction with e-book |
KRISHNA SMRITI* | 22 | KRISHNA | JUL 20. SEPT 26 - OCT 5 1970. BOMBAY. MANALI | Agrees with "Camps" + Mumbai data |
KYA ISHWAR MAR GAYA HAI?* | 08 | QUEST & ANS | ||
LAGAN MAHURAT JHOOTH SAB | 10 | QUEST & ANS | NOV 21-30 1980 | Pune One, agrees |
MAATI KAHE KUMHAR SU* | 02 | QUEST & ANS | ||
MAHAGEETA VOL 1 | 30 | ASHTAVAKRA | SEP 11 - OCT 10 1976 | Pune One, agrees |
MAHAGEETA VOL 2 | 30 | ASHTAVAKRA | NOV 11 - DEC 10 1976 | Pune One, agrees |
MAHAGEETA VOL 3 | 31 | ASHTAVAKRA | JAN 11 - FEB 10 1977 | Pune One, agrees |
MAHAVIR MERI DRISHTI MEIN | 25 | MAHAVIR | SEP 17 - OCT 01 1969. SRINAGAR | Agrees with "Camps" except Sep 17-30 |
MAHAVIR VANI VOL 1 | 18 | MAHAVIR | AUG 18 - SEP 04 1971. BOMBAY | not previously dated |
MAHAVIR VANI VOL 2 | 18 | MAHAVIR | SEP 04 - 21 1972. BOMBAY | not previously dated |
MAHAVIR VANI VOL 3 | 18 | MAHAVIR | AUG 25 - SEP 11 1973. BOMBAY | not previously dated |
MAHAVIR YA MAHAVINASH | 08 | MAHAVIR | ||
MAIN KAUN HOON*? | 10 | YOG/DHY/SADH | ||
MAIN KEHTA AAKHAN DEKHI* | 07 | QUEST & ANS | FEB 28. MAR 7-8, 10, APR 26. JUN 06-12, 16. JUL 09-10. BOMBAY | MKAD has inconsistent dates from many sources and is entangled with several other books, including Gahre Pani Paith and the two Jyotish "books" above. See MKAD's Talk page. |
MAIN MRITYU SIKHATA HOON* | 15 | MEDITATION | OCT 28-31. NOV 4-5. AUG 1-6. BOMBAY.DWARKA | No year(s) given but agrees with "Camps" re Dwarka on Oct 28-31 (1969). Likely 1969-1970 for Mumbai dates. |
MAN HI POOJA, MAN HI DHOOP | 10 | RAIDAS | OCT 01-10 1979 | Pune One, agrees |
MARO HE JOGI MARO VOL 1 | 10 | GORAKH | OCT 01-10 1978 | Pune One, agrees |
MARO HE JOGI MARO VOL 2 | 10 | GORAKH | NOV 11-20 1978 | Pune One, agrees, except Nov 11-30, wiki likely wrong, since Doc X data on Sahaj Yog (Nov 21 - Dec 10) sounder than wiki's. NB "VOL 1" and "VOL 2" "unofficial" usages only. |
MRITYORMA AMRITAMGAMAY | 10 | QUEST & ANS | AUG 01-10 1979 | Pune One, agrees |
NA KAANO SUNA, NA AANKHON DEKHA | 20 | KABIR/FARID | AKPK SEP 21-30 1975 | AKPK = Akath Kahani Prem Ki, Pune One, agrees but 10 discourses. Other sources have NKSNAD as a collective title for AKPK, a Farid book, and Honi Hoye So Hoye, a Kabir book (at other dates). |
NAHI RAM BIN THAON | 16 | QUEST & ANS | MAY 25 - JUNE 09 1973 | other sources make it May 29-Jun 9 1974 but agrees with CD-ROM (except wrong year) and fits with 16 talks. |
NAHI SAANJH NAHI BHOR | 07 | CHARANDAS | SEP 11-20 1977 | Pune One, agrees |
NAAM SUMIR MAN BAAVRE | 10 | JAGJIVAN | AUG 01-10 1978 | Pune One, agrees |
NANAK DUKHIYA SAB SANSAR* | 08 | QUEST & ANS | ** | |
NAARI AUR KRANTI* | 06 | POLI & SOC | ||
NAYE BHARAT KI KHOJ | 07 | POLI & SOC | ** | |
NAYE BHARAT KA JANM | 11 | POLI & SOC | ** | |
NAYE MANUSHYA KA DHARM* | 08 | QUEST & ANS | ** | |
NAYE SAMAJ KI KHOJ | 17 | POLI & SOC | MAR 06-09 1970. RAJKOT | Previously unlisted but these dates incomplete |
NETI-NETI : SAMBHAVANAON KI AAHAT* | 07 | YOG/DHY/SADH | Neti-Neti is a collective title for four books from meditation camps. SKK previously unlisted in "Camps" but dates have issues. SKN agrees with "Camps" and augments end date + series title. | |
NETI-NETI : SATYA KI KHOJ* | 05 | YOG/DHY/SADH | JAN 16-19 1970. BHAVNAGAR | |
NETI-NETI : SHUNYA KI NAAV* | 07 | YOG/DHY/SADH | MAY 2-5 1968. NARGOL | |
NETI-NETI : SHUNYA KE PAR* | 04 | QUEST & ANS | ||
NIRVANA UPANISHAD* | 15 | UPANISHAD | SEPT 25 - OCT 02 1971. MOUNT ABU | Agrees with "Camps" except Oct 1 |
PADH GHUNGRU BAANDH | 20 | MEERABAI | MRRDP OCT 01-10 1977. JABSK NOV 11-20 1977 | PGB a collective title for two books, Pune One, both agree |
PANTH PREM KO ATPATO* | 03 | QUEST & ANS | ** | |
PEEVAT RAMRAS LAGI KHUMARI | 08 | QUEST & ANS | JAN 11-20 1981 | Pune One, agrees |
PHIR AMRIT KI BOOND PADI | 05 | POLI & SOC | Phir Amrit and Phir Patton two of the three Hindi World Tour books. Dates for Phir Patton muddled but still helpful combined with e-book data, as with Koplein above. | |
PHIR PATTON KI PAAJEB BAJI | 11 | QUEST & ANS | OCT 27, DEC 1-3,5,8,24,26-28,30 1986. BOMBAY | |
PIV PIV LAGI PYAAS | 10 | DADU | JUL 11-20 1975 | Pune One, agrees |
PIY KO KHOJAN MAIN CHALI | 10 | QUEST & ANS | JUN 01-10 1980 | Pune One, agrees |
PRABHU MANDIR KE DWAR PAR* | 10 | QUEST & ANS | OCT 30 - NOV 03 1968. NARGOL | Agrees with "Camps" and augments end date + series title |
PREMDARSHAN* / SWAYAM KI SATTA* |
04 | YOG/DHY/SADH | ** | two separate series, not clear what connects them, if anything |
PREMGANGA* / SAMBODHI KE KSHAN |
05 | QUEST & ANS | ** | two separate series, as above |
PREM HAI DWAR PRABHU KA* | 04 | QUEST & ANS | ** | other sources call it seven discourses |
PREM NADI KE TEERA* | 16 | QUEST & ANS | ** | |
PREM PANTH AISO KATHIN | 15 | QUEST & ANS | MAR 27 - APR 10 1979 | Pune One, agrees |
PREM RANG RAS ODH CHADARIYA | 10 | DULANDAS | FEB 01-10 1979 | Pune One, agrees |
PRESS CONFERENCE | 03 | PR. INTERVIEWS | AUG 2, 4. OCT 27 1986. BOMBAY | See note above for Phir Patton. Dates duplicate other "Phir" series, hard to think of this as an independent series, never mind English title. See also Talk:Press Conferences in Hindi. |
PREETAM CHHABBI NAINAN BASEE | 16 | QUEST & ANS | JUL 11-26 1980 | Pune One, wiki has Mar 11-26, 1980 |
RAHIMAN DHAGA PREM KA | 12 | QUEST & ANS | MAR 27 - APR 10 1980 | Pune One, agrees |
RAM NAAM JAANYO NAHI | 10 | QUEST & ANS | MAR 11-20 1981 | Pune One, agrees |
RAM DUWARE JO MARE | 10 | MALUKDAS | NOV 11-18 1979 | CD ROM has many days cancelled due to chicken pox. Malukdas probably Nov 11-15 + Dec 6-10 |
ROM-ROM RAS PIJJE* | 09 | MEDITATION | ** | |
SAAKSHI KI SADHANA* | 13 | YOG/DHY/SADH | ||
SAANCH SAANCH SO SAANCH | 11 | QUEST & ANS | JAN 21-31 1981 | Pune One, agrees |
SAB-E-SAYANE EK MAT | 10 | DADU | SEP 11-20 1975 | Pune One, agrees |
SADHANA PATH: ANTAR KI YATRA*/PATH KI KHOJ* | 09 | YOG/DHY/SADH | Sadhana Path has appeared in a few forms over the years, making its pub history a bit messy. See its Talk page for details. Its appearance in precisely the forms here in Doc X is not likely. | |
SADHANA PATH: PRABHU KI PAGDANDIYAN* | 07 | YOG/DHY/SADH | ||
SADHANA SUTRA* | 20 | MABEL COLLINS | APR 06-14 1973. MOUNT ABU | Agrees with "Camps", sort of (there is already an English series on Mabel Collins at that camp; Sadhana Sutra sharing that time makes sense.) |
SAHAJ ASIKI NAAHIN | 10 | QUEST & ANS | DEC 01-10 1980 | Pune One, agrees |
SAHAJ MILE AVINASHI* | 08 | QUEST & ANS | ** | not previously listed |
SAHAJ SAMADHI BHALI | 21 | ZEN/SUFI STORIES | JUL 21 - AUG 10 1974 | Pune One, agrees |
SAHAJ YOG | 10 | SARHAPA | NOV 21 TO 30 1978 | Pune One, Dec 20 should be Dec 10, supersedes old wiki info, see note above for Maro He Jogi Maro. Re "Sarhapa", "-pa" is a common Tibetan suffix, not in conflict with "Saraha". |
SAHAJ YOG | 10 | TILOPA | DEC 01-20 1978 | |
SAHIB MIL SAHIB BHAYE | 05 | QUEST & ANS | JUL 11-20 1980 | Pune One, agrees, except 10 talks |
SAMADHI KAMAL* | 15 | YOG/DHY/SADH | ||
SAMADHI KE SAPT DWAR* | 19 | BLAVATSKY | FEB 09-17 1973. ANAND SHEELA | Agrees with "Camps" |
SAMBHOGSE SAMADHI KI OR | 16 | QUEST & ANS | AUG 28. SEPT 29 - OCT 02 1968. BOMBAY | wiki had Aug 28 + Sep 28-Oct 1, more plausible. |
SAMUNDA SAMANA BOOND ME* | 07 | QUEST & ANS | ** | |
SANTO MAGAN BHAYA MAN MERA | 19 | RAJJAB | MAY 12-31 1978 | Pune One, agrees, probably should be 20 discourses. |
SAPNA YEH SANSAR | 20 | PALTUDAS | JUL 11-30 1979 | Pune One, agrees |
SARVASAAR UPANISHAD* | 15 | UPANISHAD | JAN 08-16 1972. MATHERAN | Agrees with "Camps" |
SATYA KI PYAAS* | 08 | QUEST & ANS | ||
SHIKSHA AUR DHARM* | 05 | POLI & SOC | ||
SHIKSHA MEIN KRANTI | 22 | POLI & SOC | ||
SHIV SUTRA | 10 | SHIV | SEP 11-20 1974 | Pune One, agrees |
SHUNYA SAMADHI* | 09 | QUEST & ANS | ||
SUKH AUR SHANTI* | 09 | QUEST & ANS | ||
SUMIRAN MERA HARI KARE | 11 | QUEST & ANS | MAY 21-31 1980 | Pune One, agrees |
SUNO BHAI SADHO | 20 | MEDITATION | NOV 11-20 1974. KKB. MAR 11-20 1975 | Pune One, agrees on Nov 11-20, ten disc, KKB = Kasturi Kundal Basai, indeed at Mar dates. SBS is a collective title for the two acc to audio sites. |
SWARNA PAKHI THA JO KABHI | 22 | QUEST & ANS | Theme more Politics and Society than Q&A, subdivided into four unofficial volumes, could be 23 or 24 discourses total, 9-10 for Swarn Pakhi. | |
TAMSOMA JYOTIR-GAMAYA* | 08 | QUEST & ANS | ||
TAO UPANISHAD VOL 1 | 22 | LAO TZU | JUN 19-26, JUL 19-25, NOV 02-08 1971. BOMBAY | agrees |
TAO UPANISHAD VOL 2 | 21 | LAO TZU | FEB 29 - MAR 4, APR 31 - MAY 19, JUN 15-21 1972. BOMBAY | disagrees, wiki version hangs best. |
TAO UPANISHAD VOL 3 | 21 | LAO TZU | JUL 17-23, AUG 16-22, NOV 25 - DEC 1 1972. BOMBAY | not previously dated |
TAO UPANISHAD VOL 4 | 21 | LAO TZU | JUN 18-24, AUG 7-13, NOV 20-26 1973. BOMBAY | not previously dated |
TAO UPANISHAD VOL 5 | 21 | LAO TZU | JAN 21 - FEB 10 1975 | Pune One, agrees |
TAO UPANISHAD VOL 6 | 21 | LAO TZU | MAR 21 - APR 10 1975 | Pune One, agrees |
TRUSHA GAYEE EK BOOND SE* | 07 | YOG/DHY/SADH | ||
UDIO PANKH PASAAR | 10 | QUEST & ANS | MAY 11-20 1980 | Pune One, agrees |
UPAASNA KE KSHAN | 12 | QUEST & ANS | -- | -- |
UTSAV AMAAR JAATI, ANAND AMAAR GOTRA | 10 | QUEST & ANS | JUN 01-10 1979 | Pune One, agrees |
VIGYAN, DHARM AUR KALA* | 11 | QUEST & ANS | ||
VYAST JEEVAN ME ISHWAR KI KHOJ | 06 | QUEST & ANS | ||
YOG: NAYE AAYAM* | 06 | QUEST & ANS |
Meta-notes:
When Doc X was first discovered, it introduced a great deal of information that was not always easy to assess. After other sources also became available, it became easier to sift data and weigh it against the others to evaluate the accuracy in any particular case. But especially before Neeten's Osho Source Book, the question of how reliable was this source was a matter to be studied. The info below was compiled as part of that study, which compared how well it did in cases where data were "known", starting with the clearest and best known, Pune One.
In the comparison between Doc X and the wiki regarding dates for Pune One discourses, there is mainly agreement, as there should be since Pune One is fairly well documented in that regard. In this list there are 86 Pune One series with dates given plus two "World Tour" series from Mumbai/Manali/Kathmandu. Of those 88, there are 69 cases of straight-ahead unqualified agreement. Of the 19 others, 6 are a simple disagreement on start or end date, with at least two cases -- actually affecting four series of the six since they each involve issues where one series starts and another ends -- this list is demonstrably right and the wiki wrong. The rest are more complicated, specific notes above, with Doc X likely right in at least a few cases. Certainly there is verisimilitude in some cases. Thus, at first pass, accuracy of this list can be said to be something of the order of 74/88, or 85%, on the basis of easy comparisons to "known" material, and may be higher.
Comparing camp data is sketchier and more tenuous. Camp data are not as well documented, nor as solid, as the sole source for much of it has been Gyan Bhed, actually not even his full book but the peeks available via G**gle Books' online version. Still, here we go: There are 25 listings for camps here. 11 of them are unambiguous agreements with the wiki's "master" Camps list (MCL), including two which agree with all the data available and go the step further of adding missing data. 10 are previously unlisted in the MCL, including two in Pune which may not in fact be camps in the usual sense, ie just discourse series, but the 8 new genuine camps are welcome as provisional data.
Of the 4 others, two have end-date discrepancies, one is missing the year but agrees in other respects, and one frankly has the wrong year. That would make the "Camps" accuracy proportion 11/15, or 73%, on the basis of comparing with "known" data. Since the "known" data may be wrong in places, especially on end-dates, there is wiggle room to say it could be somewhat higher. Thus, provisional acceptance of these data seems warranted. In fact, revisiting this particular matter due to a consideration of Gyan Bhed's camp info, it looks like in a couple of these four cases, the discrepancy may have resulted from a misinterpretation of Gyan Bhed, so there may be more consensus there than previously understood.
"BOMBAY": There are 27 books dated and placed in Mumbai. Three of them concern books which also had a Camp component (Nargol, Manali and Dwarka) and one appears to be just wrong, since the dates are Pune One. That one is one of the Geeta Darshan 18-vol series, which comprise a large segment of the new dating info. Six of these are explicitly tagged Bombay (besides the erroneous one) and a further four not placed anywhere, but prior to the Pune One era. On deeper investigation (see Gita Darshan Survey), the one "wrong" one dated with Pune dates and having other errors (MAY 05-11 1974. BOMBAY, out of order, etc) appears likely to be only a typo and all would fit if May were Mar, which seems likely. Therefore an all-round boon in the Gita Darshan info sweepstakes and Bombay as well.