Talk:Main Kahta Aankhan Dekhi (मैं कहता आंखन देखी)

From The Sannyas Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search

Current Understanding

event audio,
OshoWorld
audio,
Osho.com
first published books 1979 book edition Shailendra's PDF (*1) Oshoganga Osho.com library Dates & Places
Main Kahta Aankhan Dekhi ~ 01 #1 1. सत्य सार्वभौम है Main Kahta Aankhan Dekhi, 1971 ed., 1. भेंट-वार्ता
28 Feb 1970
1. एक ज्योति संसार
28 Feb 1971, Woodland, Bombay
1. सत्य सार्वभौम है 1. सत्य सार्वभौम है
28 Feb 1971, Woodland, Bombay
1. सत्य सार्वभौम है 28 Feb 1971 om **, Woodlands, Bombay
Main Kahta Aankhan Dekhi ~ 02 #2
first sentence incomplete
2. चिन्मय कौन? अजन्मा क्या?
first sentence incomplete
Main Kahta Aankhan Dekhi, 1971 ed., 2. भेंट-वार्ता
7 Mar 1971
2. एक अनेकन नाम तुम्हारे
7 Mar 1971, Woodland, Bombay
2. चिन्मय कौन? अजन्मा क्या? 2. चिन्मय कौन? अजन्मा क्या?
7 Mar 1971, Woodland, Bombay
2. चिन्मय कौन? अजन्मा क्या? 7 Mar 1971 om **, Woodlands, Bombay
Main Kahta Aankhan Dekhi ~ 03 #3 3. आकाश जैसा शाश्वत है सत्य Main Kahta Aankhan Dekhi, 1971 ed., 3. वार्तालाप
10 Mar 1971
3. घाट ही खोजो भाई
10 Mar 1971, Woodland, Bombay
3. आकाश जैसा शाश्वत है सत्य 3. आकाश जैसा शाश्वत है सत्य
10 Mar 1971, Woodland, Bombay
3. आकाश जैसा शाश्वत है सत्य 10 Mar 1971 om **, Woodlands, Bombay
Main Kahta Aankhan Dekhi ~ 04 #4 4. धर्म की गति और तेज हो! Main Kahta Aankhan Dekhi, 1971 ed., 4. वार्तालाप
12 Mar 1971
4. जोति-सरूपी आत्मा
12 Mar 1971, Woodland, Bombay
4. धर्म की गति और तेज हो! 4. धर्म की गति और तेज हो!
12 Mar 1971, Woodland, Bombay
4. धर्म की गति और तेज हो! 12 Mar 1971 pm, Woodlands, Bombay
Gahre Pani Paith ~ 01 Gahre Pani Peth #4 Gahre Pani Paith 1. मंदिर के आंतरिक अर्थ Gahre Pani Paith (गहरे पानी पैठ), 1971 ed., 1. मन्दिर 5. मंदिर
missing first question, talk starts with its response
26 Apr 1971, Woodland, Bombay
5. मंदिर के आंतरिक अर्थ 5. मंदिर के आंतरिक अर्थ
26 Apr 1971, Woodland, Bombay
Gahre Pani Paith 1. मंदिर के आंतरिक अर्थ 26 Apr 1971 pm, Woodlands, Bombay
Gahre Pani Paith ~ 02 Gahre Pani Peth #3 Gahre Pani Paith 2. तीर्थः परम की गुह्य यात्रा Gahre Pani Paith (गहरे पानी पैठ), 1971 ed., 2. तीर्थ
missing first question, talk starts with its response
6. तीर्थ
missing first question, talk starts with its response
6 Jun 1971, Bombay
6. तीर्थ : परम की गुह्य यात्रा 6. तीर्थ : परम की गुह्म यात्रा
missing first question, talk starts with its response
6 Jun 1971, Bombay
Gahre Pani Paith 2. तीर्थ: परम की गुह्य यात्रा 6 Jun 1971 pm, Woodlands, Bombay
Gahre Pani Paith ~ 03 Gahre Pani Peth #2 Gahre Pani Paith 3. तिलक-टीकेः तृतीय नेत्र की अभिव्यंजना Gahre Pani Paith (गहरे पानी पैठ), 1971 ed., 3.तिलक-टीके
missing first question, talk starts with its response
7. तिलक-टीके
missing first question, talk starts with its response
12 Jun 1971, Woodland, Bombay
7. तिलक-टीकेः तृतीय नेत्र की अभिव्यंजना 7. तिलक—टीके : तृतीय नेत्र की अभिव्यंजना
missing first question, talk starts with its response
12 Jun 1971, Woodland, Bombay
Gahre Pani Paith 3. तिलक-टीके: तृतीय नेत्र की अभिव्यंजना 12 Jun 1971 pm, Woodlands, Bombay
Gahre Pani Paith ~ 04 Gahre Pani Peth #1 Gahre Pani Paith 4. मूर्ति-पूजाः मूर्त से अमूर्त की ओर Gahre Pani Paith (गहरे पानी पैठ), 1971 ed., 4. मूर्ति-पूजा
missing first question, talk starts with its response
8. मूर्ति-पूजा
missing first question, talk starts with its response
16 Jun 1971, Woodland, Bombay
8. मूर्ति-पूजाः मूर्त से अमूर्त की ओर 8. मूर्ति—पूजा : से अमूर्त की और
missing first question, talk starts with its response
16 Jun 1971, Woodland, Bombay
Gahre Pani Paith 4. मूर्ति-पूजा: मूर्त से अमूर्त की ओर 16 Jun 1971, 20:30, Woodlands, Bombay
Jyotish Vigyan ~ 01 Jyotish Adwait Ka Vigyan #1 Jyotish Vigyan 1. ज्योतिष: अद्वैत का विज्ञान
missing first question, audio starts with its response
Jyotish: Advait Ka Vigyan (ज्योतिष : अद्वैत का विज्ञान), 1972 ed.
9 Jul 1971, Bombay
9. ज्योतिष : अद्वैत का विज्ञान
9 Jul 1971, Bombay
9. ज्योतिषः अद्वैत का विज्ञान 9. ज्योतिष : अद्वैत का विज्ञान
9 Jul 1971, Woodland, Bombay
Jyotish Vigyan 1. ज्योतिष: अद्वैत का विज्ञान 9 Jul 1971 pm, Woodlands, Bombay
Jyotish Vigyan ~ 02 Jyotish Adwait Ka Vigyan #2 Jyotish Vigyan 2. ज्योतिष अर्थात अध्यात्म Jyotish Arthat Adhyatma (ज्योतिष अर्थात् अध्यात्म), 1972 ed.
10 Jul 1971, Bombay
10. ज्योतिष अर्थात् अध्यात्म
10 Jul 1971, Bombay
10. ज्योतिष अर्थात अध्यात्म 10. ज्योतिष अर्थात अध्यात्म
10 Jul 1971, Woodland, Bombay
Jyotish Vigyan 2. ज्योतिष अर्थात अध्यात्म 10 Jul 1971 pm, Woodlands, Bombay
Main Kaun Hun (writings) ~ 01 Main Kaun Hun? (मैं कौन हूं?) (writings), 1967 ed., 1. "मैं कौन हूं?" 11. मैं कौन हूं ? 11. मैं कौन हूं? 11. मैं कौन हूं?
1966-67
< 1967, Jabalpur (*2)
Main Kaun Hun (writings) ~ 02 Main Kaun Hun? (मैं कौन हूं?) (writings), 1967 ed., 2. धर्म क्या है? 12. धर्म क्या है 12. धर्म क्या है? 12. धर्म क्या है?
1966-67
< 1967 (*2)
Main Kaun Hun (writings) ~ 03 Main Kaun Hun? (मैं कौन हूं?) (writings), 1967 ed., 3. विज्ञान की अग्नि में : धर्म विश्वास 13. विज्ञान की अग्नि में धर्म और विश्वास 13. विज्ञान की अग्नि में धर्म और विश्वास 13. विज्ञान की अग्नि में धर्म और विश्वास
1966-67
< 1967 (*2)
Main Kaun Hun (writings) ~ 04 Main Kaun Hun? (मैं कौन हूं?) (writings), 1967 ed., 4. मनुष्य का विज्ञान 14. मनुष्य का विज्ञान 14. मनुष्य का विज्ञान 14. मनुष्य का विज्ञान
1966-67
< 1967 (*2)
Main Kaun Hun (writings) ~ 05 Main Kaun Hun? (मैं कौन हूं?) (writings), 1967 ed., 5. विचार के जन्म के लिये : विचारों से मुक्ति 15. विचार के जन्म के लिए : विचारों से मुक्ति 15. विचार के जन्म के लिएः विचारों से मुक्ति 15. विचार के जन्म के लिए : विचारों से मुक्ति
1966-67
< 1967, Jabalpur (*2)
Main Kaun Hun (writings) ~ 06 Main Kaun Hun? (मैं कौन हूं?) (writings), 1967 ed., 6. जीयें और जानें 16. जीएं और जानें 16. जीएं और जानें 16. जीये और जानें
1966-67
< 1967 (*2)
Main Kaun Hun (writings) ~ 07 Main Kaun Hun? (मैं कौन हूं?) (writings), 1967 ed., 7. शिक्षा का लक्ष्य 17. शिक्षा का लक्ष्य 17. शिक्षा का लक्ष्य 17. शिक्षा का लक्ष्य
1966-67 (*3)
< 1967 (*2)
Main Kaun Hun (writings) ~ 08 Main Kaun Hun? (मैं कौन हूं?) (writings), 1967 ed., 8. जीवन संपदा का अधिकार 18. जीवन-सम्पदा का अधिकार 18. जीवन-संपदा का अधिकार 18. जीवन—संपदा का अधिकार
1966-67
< 1967 (*2)
Main Kaun Hun (writings) ~ 09 Main Kaun Hun? (मैं कौन हूं?) (writings), 1967 ed., 9. समाधि योग 19. समाधि योग 19. समाधि योग 19. समाधि योग
1966-67
< 1967 (*2)
Main Kaun Hun (writings) ~ 10 Main Kaun Hun? (मैं कौन हूं?) (writings), 1967 ed., 10. जीवन की अदृश्य जडें 20. जीवन की अदृश्य जड़ें 20. जीवन की अदृश्य जड़ें 20. जीवन की अदृश्य जड़ें
1966-67
< 1967 (*2)
Main Kaun Hun (writings) ~ 11 Main Kaun Hun? (मैं कौन हूं?) (writings), 1967 ed., 11. अहिन्सा क्या है? 21. अहिंसा क्या है ? 21. अहिंसा क्या है? 21. अहिंसा क्या है?
1966-67
< 1967 (*2)
Main Kaun Hun (writings) ~ 12 Main Kaun Hun? (मैं कौन हूं?) (writings), 1967 ed., 12. आनन्द की दिशा 22. आनन्द की दिशा 22. आनंद की दिशा 22. आनंद की दिशा
1966-67
< 1967 (*2)
Main Kaun Hun (writings) ~ 13 Main Kaun Hun? (मैं कौन हूं?) (writings), 1967 ed., 13. मांगो और मिलेगा 23. मांगो और मिलेगा 23. मांगो और मिलेगा 23. मांगो और मिलेगा
1966-67
< 1967 (*2)
Main Kaun Hun (writings) ~ 14 Main Kaun Hun? (मैं कौन हूं?) (writings), 1967 ed., 14. प्रेम ही प्रभु है 24. प्रेम ही प्रभु है 24. प्रेम ही प्रभु है 24. प्रेम ही प्रभु है
1966-67
< 1967 (*2)
Main Kaun Hun (writings) ~ 15 Main Kaun Hun? (मैं कौन हूं?) (writings), 1967 ed., 15. नीति, भय और प्रेम 25. नीति, भय और प्रेम 25. नीति, भय और प्रेम 25. नीति, भय और प्रेम
1966-67
< 1967 (*2)
Main Kaun Hun (writings) ~ 16 Main Kaun Hun? (मैं कौन हूं?) (writings), 1967 ed., 16. अहिन्सा का अर्थ 26. अहिंसा का अर्थ 26. अहिंसा का अर्थ 26. अहिंसा का अर्थ
1966-67
< 1967 (*2)
Main Kaun Hun (writings) ~ 17 Main Kaun Hun? (मैं कौन हूं?) (writings), 1967 ed., 17. मैं मृत्यु सिखाता हूं 27. मैं मृत्यु सिखाता हूं 27. मैं मृत्यु सिखाता हूं 27. मैं मृत्यु सिखाता हूं
1966-67
< 1967 (*2)
Nirvan Upanishad ~ 11 Nirvan Upanishad #11
missing meditaiton part
Nirvan Upanishad 11. अंतर-आकाश में उड़ान, स्वतंत्रता का दायित्व
sutra revoiced, missing meditaiton part
(book is not available for wiki in order to check) 28. यह मन क्या है ?
(here is part of event only)
  • 28. यह मन क्या है?
    (here is part of event only)
  • Nirvan Upanishad 11. अंतर-आकाश में उड़ान, स्वतंत्रता का दायित्व और शक्तियां प्रभु-मिलन की ओर
    missing meditaiton part
  • 28. यह मन क्या है?
    (here is part of event only)
    1970-71
  • Nirvan Upanishad 11. अंतर—आकाश में उड़ान, स्वतंत्रता का दायित्व और शक्तियां प्रभु—मिलन की और
    missing meditaiton part
Nirvan Upanishad 11. अंतर-आकाश में उड़ान, स्वतंत्रता का दायित्व और शक्तियां प्रभु-मिलन की ओर
missing meditaiton part
30 Sep 1971 pm, Mount Abu, meditation camp
Geeta-Darshan Adhyaya 06 ~ 03 Geeta Darshan Vol 6 #3
missing meditation part
Gita Darshan, Adhyaya 6, 3. मालकियत की घोषणा
meditation part incomplete (more complete than OW audio)
(book is not available for wiki in order to check) 29. जो बोएंगे बीज वही काटेंगे फसल
(here is part of event only)
  • 29. जो बोएंगे बीज वही काटेंगे फसल
    (here is part of event only)
  • Geeta Darshan, Bhag 3, Adhyaya 6, 3. मालकियत की घोषणा
  • 29. जो बोएंगे बीज वही काटेंगे फसल
    (here is part of event only)
    1970-71
  • Geeta Darshan, Bhag-3, Adhyaya 6, 3. मालकियत की घोषणा
Gita-Darshan, Adhyaya 6, 3. मालकियत की घोषणा 3 May 1971 pm, Ahmedabad
Geeta-Darshan Adhyaya 04 ~ 13 Geeta Darshan Vol 4 #13
missing meditation part
Gita Darshan, Adhyaya 4, 13. मृत्यु का साक्षात
sutra revoiced, meditation part incomplete (more complete than OW audio)
(book is not available for wiki in order to check) 30. मृत्यु और परलोक
(here is part of event only)
  • 30. मृत्यु और परलोक
    (here is part of event only)
  • Geeta Darshan, Bhag 2, Adhyaya 4, 13. मृत्यु का साक्षात
  • 30. मृत्यु और परलोक
    (here is part of event only)
    1970-71
  • Geeta Darshan, Bhag-2, Adhyaya 4, 13. मृत्यु का साक्षात
Gita-Darshan, Adhyaya 4, 13. मृत्यु का साक्षात 5 Feb 1971 am, Poona
Geeta-Darshan Adhyaya 04 ~ 18 Geeta Darshan Vol 4 #18
meditation part incomplete (more complete than osho.com version)
Gita Darshan, Adhyaya 4, 18. संशयात्मा विनश्यति
sutra revoiced, meditation part incomplete
(book is not available for wiki in order to check) 31. भगवत्प्रेम
(here is part of event only)
  • 31. भगवत्-प्रेम
    (here is part of event only)
  • Geeta Darshan, Bhag 2, Adhyaya 4, 18. संशयात्मा विनश्यति
  • 31. भगवत—प्रेम
    (here is part of event only)
    1970-71
  • Geeta Darshan, Bhag-2, Adhyaya 4, 18. संशयात्मा विनश्यति
Gita-Darshan, Adhyaya 4, 18. संशयात्मा विनश्यति 7 Feb 1971 pm, Poona
(book is not available for wiki in order to check) 32. जागते...जागते…, devided on 4 parts: 32. जागते-जागते…, devided on 4 parts: 32. जागते—जागते....., (1970-71), devided on 4 parts:
Geeta-Darshan Adhyaya 04 ~ 14 Geeta Darshan Vol 4 #14
meditation part incomplete
Gita Darshan, Adhyaya 4, 14. चरण-स्पर्श और गुरु-सेवा
sutra revoiced, meditation part incomplete
(book is not available for wiki in order to check) :part 1. परमात्मा की चाह नहीं हो सकती
(here is part of event only)
  • part 1. परमात्मा की चाह नहीं हो सकती
    (here is part of event only)
  • Geeta Darshan, Bhag 2, Adhyaya 4, 14. चरण-स्पर्श और गुरु-सेवा
  • part 1. परमात्मा की चाह नहीं हो सकती
    (here is part of event only)
  • Geeta Darshan, Bhag-2, Adhyaya 4, 14. चरण-स्पर्श और गुरु-सेवा
Gita-Darshan, Adhyaya 4, 14. चरण-स्पर्श और गुरु-सेवा 5 Feb 1971 pm, Poona
Geeta-Darshan Adhyaya 04 ~ 13 Geeta Darshan Vol 4 #13
missing meditation part
Gita Darshan, Adhyaya 4, 13. मृत्यु का साक्षात
sutra revoiced, meditation part incomplete (more complete than OW audio)
(book is not available for wiki in order to check) :part 2. भागे हिरन और भटके राम
(here is part of event only)
  • part 2. भागे हिरन और भटके राम
    (here is part of event only)
  • Geeta Darshan, Bhag 2, Adhyaya 4, 13. मृत्यु का साक्षात
  • part 2. भागे हिरण और भटके राम
    (here is part of event only)
  • Geeta Darshan, Bhag-2, Adhyaya 4, 13. मृत्यु का साक्षात
Gita-Darshan, Adhyaya 4, 13. मृत्यु का साक्षात 5 Feb 1971 am, Poona
Geeta-Darshan Adhyaya 04 ~ 15 Geeta Darshan Vol 4 #15
missing meditation part
Gita Darshan, Adhyaya 4, 15. मोह का टूटना
meditation part incomplete
(book is not available for wiki in order to check) :part 3. पाप कभी पुण्य से नहीं कटता
(here is part of event only)
  • part 3. पाप कभी पुण्य से नहीं कटता
    (here is part of event only)
  • Geeta Darshan, Bhag 2, Adhyaya 4, 15. मोह का टूटना
  • part 3. पाप कभी पुण्य से नहीं कटता
    (here is part of event only)
  • Geeta Darshan, Bhag-2, Adhyaya 4, 15. मोह का टूटना
Gita-Darshan, Adhyaya 4, 15. मोह का टूटना 6 Feb 1971 am, Poona
Geeta-Darshan Adhyaya 04 ~ 05 Geeta Darshan Vol 4 #5
meditation part incomplete
Gita Darshan, Adhyaya 4, 5. जीवन एक लीला
at least first question revoiced, meditation part incomplete
(book is not available for wiki in order to check) :part 4. धर्म संस्थापनार्थाय….
(here is part of event only)
  • part 4. धर्म संस्थापनार्थाय
    (here is part of event only)
  • Geeta Darshan, Bhag 2, Adhyaya 4, 5. जीवन एक लीला
  • part 4. धर्म संस्थापनार्थाय
    (here is part of event only)
  • Geeta Darshan, Bhag-2, Adhyaya 4, 5. जीवन एक लीला
Gita-Darshan, Adhyaya 4, 5. जीवन एक लीला 1 Feb 1971 am, Poona
Ishavasya Upanishad ~ 10 Ishavashya Upanishad #10
missing meditation part
Ishavasya Upanishad 10. वह शून्य है
sutra revoiced, missing meditation part
(book is not available for wiki in order to check) 33. ब्रह्म के दो रूप
(here is part of event only)
  • 33. ब्रह्म के दो रूप
    (here is part of event only)
  • Ishavashya Upanishad 10. वह ब्रह्म है
  • 33. ब्रह्म के दो रूप
    (here is part of event only)
    1970-71
  • Ishavashya Upanishad 10. वह ब्रह्म है
Ishavasya Upanishad 10. वह ब्रह्म है 9 Apr 1971 am, Koda House, Mount Abu, meditation camp
Krishna Meri Drishti Mein ~ 22 Krishna Smriti #22 Krishna Smriti 22. परिशिष्ट: नव-संन्यास Nav-Sannyas Kya? (नव-संन्यास क्या?), 1972 ed., 1. एक तरल, गैर-गंभीर व आनंद पूर्ण संन्यास का सूत्र-पात
28 Sep 1970 pm, med.camp Manali (H.P.)
34. एक तरल, गैर-गम्भीर व आनन्दपूर्ण संन्यास का सूत्र-पात
28 Sep 1970 pm, med. camp., Manali (H.P.)
  • 34. नव-संन्यास का सूत्रपात
  • Nav-Sannyas Kya 1. नव-संन्यास का सूत्रपात
  • Krishna Smriti 22. नव-संन्यास
    additional meeting, 28 Sep 1970 pm
  • 34. नव—संन्यास का सूत्रपात
    28 Sep 1970 pm, Manali med. camp
  • Nav-Sannyas Kya? 1. नव-संन्यास का सूत्रपात
Krishna Smriti 22. नव-संन्यास 28 Sep 1970 pm, Manali (HP), meditation camp
Nav-Sannyas Kya ~ 01 #5
beginning and end incomplete
Nav Sannyas Kya 1. संन्यासः नई दिशा, नया बोध
"No beginning, no ending, sound dropouts"
Nav-Sannyas Kya? (नव-संन्यास क्या?), 1972 ed., 2. संन्यास : नयी दिशा, नया बोध
beginning and end incomplete
20 Oct 1970, Poona (Maharashtr.)
35. संन्यास : नयी दिशा, नया बोध
beginning and end incomplete
20 Oct 1970, Poona
  • 40. संन्यासः नयी दिशा, नया बोध
    beginning and end incomplete
  • Nav-Sannyas Kya 2. संन्यासः नयी दिशा, नया बोध
    beginning and end incomplete
  • 35. संन्यास : नयी दिशा, नया बोध
    beginning and end incomplete
    20 Oct 1970
  • Nav Sannyas Kya? 2. संन्यासः नयी दिशा, नया बोध
    beginning and end incomplete
Nav-Sannyas Kya? 1. संन्यास: नई दिशा, नया बोध
beginning and end incomplete
20 Oct 1970, Poona
Nav-Sannyas Kya ~ 04 Nav Sannyas Kya 4. "Audio Not Available" Nav-Sannyas Kya? (नव-संन्यास क्या?), 1972 ed., 3. संन्यास और संसार
first week of Nov 1970, Jabalpur residence
36. संन्यास और संसार
first week of November 1970, Jabalpur
  • 35. संन्यास और संसार
  • Nav-Sannyas Kya 3. संन्यास और संसार
  • 36. संन्यास और संसार
    first week of Nov 1970, Jabalpur
  • Nav Sannyas Kya? 3. (no title)
Nav-Sannyas Kya? 4. संन्यास और संसार 1 - 7 Nov 1970, Kamala Nehru Nagar, Jabalpur
Suli Upar Sej Piya Ki ~ 04 Jyon Ki Tyon #9
first sentences are untranscribed
Jyon Ki Tyon Dhari Deenhi Chadariya 9. अचौर्य (प्रश्नोत्तर)
first sentences are untranscribed
Nav-Sannyas Kya? (नव-संन्यास क्या?), 1972 ed., 4. संन्यास के फूल : संसार की भूमि में
(only last question)
13 and 14 Nov 1970, night, Cross Maidan, Bombay, fragments (*4)
37. संन्यास के फूल : संसार की भूमि में
(only last question)
13 and 14 Nov 1970, parts of night talks, Cross Maidan, Bombay (*4)
  • 36. संन्यास के फूलः संसार की भूमि में
    (only last question)
  • Nav-Sannyas Kya 4. संन्यास के फूलः संसार की भूमि में
    (only last question)
  • Jyon Ki Tyon Dhari Dinhi Chadariya 9. अचौर्य (प्रश्नोत्तर)
  • 37. संन्यास के फूल: संसार की भूमि में
    (only last question)
    13 and 14 Nov 1970, Cross Maidan, Bombay (*4)
  • 'Jyon Ki Tyon Dhari Dinhi Chadariya 9. अचौर्य
Jyon Ki Tyon Dhari Deenhi Chadariya 9. अचौर्य (प्रश्नोत्तर)
(beginning of first question is complete)
13 Nov 1970 am, Cross Maidan, Bombay
Nav-Sannyas Kya ~ 02 #6
(it looks complete)
Nav Sannyas Kya 2. आनंद व अहोभाव में डूबा हुआ नव-संन्यास (first part, i.e. before 52:26) (*5)
(it looks complete)
Nav-Sannyas Kya? (नव-संन्यास क्या?), 1972 ed., 5. आनन्द व अहोभाव में डूबा हुआ--नव-संन्यास
text edited, end incomplete
6 Dec 1970, Ahmedabad
38. आनन्द व अहोभाव में हुआ--नव-संन्यास
text edited, end incomplete
6 Dec 1970, Ahmedabad
  • 41. आनंद व अहोभाव में डूबा हुआ नव-संन्यास (complete)
  • Nav-Sannyas Kya 5. आनंद व अहोभाव में डूबा हुआ नव-संन्यास
    text edited, end incomplete
  • 38. आनंद व अहोभाव में डूबा हुआ नव—संन्यास
    text edited, end incomplete
    6 Dec 1970, Ahmedabad
  • Nav Sannyas Kya? 5. आनंद व अहोभाव में डूबा हुआ नव-संन्यास
    text edited, end incomplete
Nav-Sannyas Kya? 2. आनंद व अहोभाव में डूबा हुआ नव-संन्यास (complete) 6 Dec 1970 pm, Ahmedabad
This chapter is the compilation from two events: Nav-Sannyas Kya? (नव-संन्यास क्या?), 1972 ed., 6. संन्यास का एक नया अभियान
missing first question itself and text starts with its response
first weeks of Jan and Feb 1971, Bombay and Poona, two parts of discourses
39. संन्यास का एक नया अभियान
missing first question, text starts with its response
first week of January 1971, Bombay, and first week of February 1971, Poona
  • 37. संन्यास का एक नया अभियान
  • Nav-Sannyas Kya 6. संन्यास का एक नया अभियान
  • 39. संन्यास का एक नया अभियान
    missing first question, text starts with its response
    first week of January 1971, Bombay, and first week of February 1971
  • Nav Sannyas Kya? 4. (no title)
    missing first question itself and text starts with its response
  • Nav Sannyas Kya? 6. (no title)
    missing first question itself and text starts with its response
3 Feb 1971 pm, Poona and 2 Jan 1971 pm, Cross Maidan, Bombay
Anant Ki Pukar ~ 02 Anant Ki Pukar #5 Anant Ki Pukar 2. एक एक कदम Nav-Sannyas Kya? (नव-संन्यास क्या?), 1972 ed., 7. संन्यास का एक नया आयाम : अल्प कालीन संन्यास
here is only beginning of the event
med.camp, Lonavala (Maharashtr.)
40. संन्यास का एक नया आयाम : अल्पकालीन संन्यास
here is only beginning of the event
24 Dec 1967, med. camp, Lonavala (Maharsh.)
  • 38. सावधिक संन्यास की धारणा
    here is only beginning of the event
  • Nav-Sannyas Kya first part of 7. सावधिक संन्यास की धारणा (p.63-64)
    here is only beginning of the event
  • Anant Ki Pukar 5. अवधिगत संन्यास
  • 40. सावधिक संन्यास की धारणा
    here is only beginning of the event
    24 Dec 1967, med. camp, Lonavala (Maharsh.)
  • Nav Sannyas Kya? 7. (no title, first part)
    here is only beginning of the event
  • Anant Ki Pukar 5. अवधिगत संन्यास
Anant Ki Pukar 2. अवधिगत संन्यास 24 Dec 1967 am, Lonavala
Nav-Sannyas Kya ~ 03 #7 Nav Sannyas Kya 2. पूरब की श्रेष्ठतम देन (second part, i.e. from 52:26) (*5) Nav-Sannyas Kya? (नव-संन्यास क्या?), 1972 ed., 8. मनुष्यता को पूरब की श्रेष्ठतम देन--संन्यास
3 Jul 1971, 7:45 pm, All India Radio, Bombay, radio weekly program "Manobhumi": "संन्यास मेरी दृष्टि में"
41. मनुष्यता को पूरब की श्रेष्ठतम देन--संन्यास
3 Jul 1971, 7:45 pm, All India Radio, Bombay, radio talk "संन्यास मेरी दृष्टि में"
  • 42. पूरब की श्रेष्ठतम देनः संन्यास
  • Nav-Sannyas Kya middle part of 7. सावधिक संन्यास की धारणा (p.64-66)
  • 41. की पूरब श्रेष्ठतम देन : संन्यास
    3 Jul 1971, All India Radio, Bombay, radio talk
  • Nav Sannyas Kya? 7. (no title, middle part)
Nav-Sannyas Kya? 3. पूरब की श्रेष्ठतम देनः संन्यास 3 Jul 1971, 19:45, All India Radio, Bombay
Nav-Sannyas Kya ~ 05 Nav Sannyas Kya 5. "Audio Not Available" Nav-Sannyas Kya? (नव-संन्यास क्या?), 1972 ed., 9. संन्यास का निर्णय और ध्यान में छलांग
26 Nov 1971, Poona, before morning meditation, first half of q/a talk
42. संन्यास का निर्णय और ध्यान में छलांग
26 Nov 1971, Poona, "first half of q/a talk"
  • 39. संन्यास का निर्णय और ध्यान में छलांग
  • Nav-Sannyas Kya last part of 7. सावधिक संन्यास की धारणा (p.66-68)
  • 42. संन्यास का निर्णय और ध्यान में छलांग
    26 Nov 1971, Poona
  • Nav Sannyas Kya? 7. (no title, last part)
Nav-Sannyas Kya? 5. संन्यास का निर्णय और ध्यान में छलांग 26 Nov 1971 am, Poona
It's chapter with 39 letters, details on them see in Talk:Nav-Sannyas Kya? (नव-संन्यास क्या?) Nav-Sannyas Kya? (नव-संन्यास क्या?), 1972 ed., 10. पात्र-पाथेय--संन्यासियों के लिए 43. पत्र-पाथेय--संन्यासियों के लिए
  • 43. पत्र-पाथेयः संन्यासियों के लिए
  • Nav-Sannyas Kya 8. पत्र-पाथेय
Notes
(*1) Order of chapters of Shailendra's PDF match to 1996 and 2006 editions and differs from order of 1979.
(*2) As Main Kaun Hun? was first published in Mar 1967, then unlikely that 1967 is date of writings.
(*3) Date no stated actually, we assume it was skipped accidentally as all 16 chapters have it.
(*4) See footnote (*3) on Talk:Nav-Sannyas Kya? (नव-संन्यास क्या?).
(*5) 2nd and 3rd talks are selling as one audio #2 on osho.com.

Deliberations

The principal source of the confusion surrounding and permeating this book appears to be wires crossed with Gahre Pani Paith (गहरे पानी पैठ). Thus it will be useful to explore the relationship of these two books, since their overlapping/merging is deep-rooted and long-standing. This exploration and ancillary matters have been left more or less as they were originally written. Resolution awaits at the end!


The numbers game

A good framework for dealing with all this can come from considering the amazing variety of choices for number of discourses. Various sources suggest four, six, seven, ten, thirteen, thirty-three and beyond. So:

Four: In recent years, the Diamond and OMI editions have both had four chapters, with the same titles in the same order and with the page count the same order of magnitude. This is good, has an appearance of solidity.

Six: According to the CD-ROM, Dimensions Beyond the Known, MKAD's translation, has six chapter-discourses. This also seems like a relatively solid datum, corroborated by numerous editions of Dimensions.

For parallel-universe fans, let it also be noted that Gahre has its four-and-six aspects. The six is again the CD-ROM, ie it shows six discourse-chapters for Gahre's translation, Hidden Mysteries, and the four is Gahre "itself." It is augmented by two one-chapter booklets on Jyotish, Indian Astrology, to make six in the translation. And a fairly useless factoid but nonetheless interesting: the 2012 Diamond edition of Gahre and the 2010 OMI edition of MKAD have exactly the same picture of Osho, not exactly a high-odds possibility. Got the hair on the back of your neck standing on end yet?

Seven: Many of the Indian free download audio sites have seven mp3-discourses. Most will be based on Osho World's seven, but since they have no titles, this might be considered a little less solid, but, okay, let that fact be noted.

For ten we have, from Osho World again, an audiobook offering for the two Jyotish discourses, which they identify as "Mai Kahta Ankhan Dekhi, 9 to 10". You might wonder about the first eight chapters of MKAD in OW's audiobook section. Where and what are they? One has to dig deep but they do have at least 1 to 4 and, mirabile dictu, with the same titles as the other guys in the four-chapter print TOC below.

And we have "Doc X", giving dates for MKAD that have a few small mistakes but basically correspond to dates for the first four of MKAD plus the whole of Gahre, plus the two Jyotish dates. This sort of aligns with the sort of ten of Osho World's audiobook (sans Gahre's four).

The one source of the thirteen info has an excellent record of sorting out these kinds of discrepancies, and that is Tao Vision. So what do they have to offer this time? Well, they assert that MKAD is the über-name of an amalgamation of four smaller volumes: the four-discourse versions of MKAD and Gahre, two discourses worth of Jyotish and a three-discourse volume called "Sannyas". This thirteen-theory can thus sort of account for all the other lower numbers AND for the confusion with Gahre. Is that all there is to it?

Well, not exactly. There is also Neeten to consider. He has a few references to MKAD in his Osho Source Book which muddy the waters at first but with some patience they will help, and a first edition cover image is not to be sniffed at.

From his Bibliography section: Main Kahata Akhem Dekhi (What I'm telling you I've seen with my own Eyes). Jevan Jagruti Kendra, 1971. 136 p. 1st ed. Colored front and back. Alt.t.: Hidden Mysteries.
From his Appendix: Main Kahta Akhan Dekhi (Dimensions Beyond the Known). 28.02.70-09.07.71.(1973). 7 talks. Bombay. (A)
and Main Kehata Ankhan Dekhi. 28.02-10.07.1971. 10 talks. Poona.
and from the Bombay section: the image used for the first cover, though without any info attached.

Okay. So Neeten has got into the spirit of entangling Gahre and MKAD. His book cover image matches the description of the cover in his Bibliography section and though there is nothing on that cover to suggest Gahre, either as a component of MKAD or whatever, the alt-title suggested is of course Gahre's translation title. And the 1971 pub date is a puzzler, as the CD-ROM says the final discourses of MKAD were not given until 1973. Can this be a misbegotten Gahre cover, even though it reads MKAD in Devanagari? Resolution awaits below.

To finish off the numbers-of-discourses exploration, the 33 comes from a G**gle Books peek inside the 2006 Diamond Books edition of Kranti Sutra (क्रांति सूत्र) (compilation). Diamond says that Kranti was previously published as chapters 11-33 of MKAD. We can quibble or not about the fact that it actually has only 22 chapters, not 23, but note that those 22 chapters are fairly short, only coming to 168 pages. Thus, if we consider what a 33-chapter MKAD might look like, it will not be the purported 525-page monster of the 1988 Tao edition. (How about 325? Could 525 be a mistake? What kind of scenario would 525 pages fit anyway, irrespective of Kranti? Perhaps a 57-chapter version is lurking there.)


To check if content of Main Kahta Aankhan Dekhi 2 (मैं कहता आंखन देखी २) is the same as current book. Title page has not "2". So if it is the same book, then it needs to move that edition to this book.--DhyanAntar 13:44, 6 October 2020 (UTC)

Yes, it's the same content as later Rebel edition. "2" was added to its cover in order to distinguish with previous 4-chapter version. As title page don't have this "2", then it that 1979 edition was moved to current page.--DhyanAntar 17:05, 7 October 2020 (UTC)

Some miscellaneous infobits

And ya never know: In a G**gle Books peek inside the Diamond Books edition of Nav-Sannyas Kya? (नव-संन्यास क्या?), Diamond says that some of that book's material -- not clear what or how much -- is from MKAD discourse 34. This is in some ways too outrageous to be true, so it would be premature to give this rumour the same status as some of the other chapter count info, especially remembering that Diamond is the source of the rumour that Kranti was originally ch 11-33 of MKAD. But Nav-Sannyas may resonate with the fourth component volume cited by Tao Vision, "Sannyas", in some way not yet apparent, so we'll keep it around.


Meanwhile, the four-discourse chapter titles of OMI's and Diamond's recent books, and osho.com's and Osho World's audiobooks are all the same. This is the feature with the strongest resonance in all this vast array of infobits and rumours. To add to that, the Hindi blurb for the book describes it as autobiographical, in keeping with the autobiographical themes of the English chapter titles and indeed of the book's title (roughly "I am saying what my eyes have seen"), though these chapter titles seem unrelated to those of Dimensions:

1. सत्य सार्वभौम है
2. चिन्मय कौन? अजन्मा क्या?
3. आकाश जैसा शाश्वत है सत्य
4. धर्म की गति ओर तेज हो!

Possibly the features that have been the most misleading in this whole business are these English translations. Why, when most sources associate the two Jyotish chapters with MKAD, were they grafted onto Gahre in Hidden Mysteries? And where did those two other chapters of Dimensions come from? Were they ever published in another context? Is their original language even known? They may have been sensible English publishing decisions but as far as MKAD is concerned, it makes more sense to leave them out of any reckoning. Then we are not distracted by their 1973ness when considering the 1971 edition, which can now have an unambiguous four chapters. Yes!


Finally, a note on transliteration. MKAD has more than its share of transliteration variety, with Mein, Mai, Kehta, Kahata, Akhan, Ankhan and more showing up. The good news is that it doesn't seem to interfere much with relatively complete searches, except that searches for Main and Mein don't find Mai. -- Updated doofus-9 (talk) 16:55, 27 March 2015 (UTC)


Just some stray info. OshoWorld, in their download Hindi section, has 7 mp3s for Main Kahta Akhan Dekhi, numbered as #1 - #7.

But before 2015, they had a Lower Quality collection. Those were also 7 mp3s, same content, but numbered as #1, 2, 3, 4, 40, 41, 42.

I have sometimes seen the numbering of the LQ mp3s to be more correct than the HQ mp3s. --Sugit (talk) 10:52, 15 December 2015 (UTC)


OTOH, 40, 41 and 42 is fairly bizarre when we have been considering all the different possibilities of numbers of talks but have not got above 34 , and that a mighty stretch. -- doofus-9 06:50, 6 March 2016 (UTC)


A consideration of dates

Main Kahta Aankhan Dekhi Jagdish dates.jpg

The two entries in Neeten's Appendix section for MKAD merit a closer look, focusing on the dates. One interesting thing is that they both start with Feb 28 but on different years. Might this suggest a possible error somewhere along the line, a wee crossed wire?

Neeten mentions MKAD in the text of his Bombay section as well, and comes up with four specific dates, which are the same dates as the wiki has been using for the first four talks, and which come from the CD-ROM, except that the first one is Feb 28 1971, not the Feb 28 1970 that is in the CD-ROM. Considering that he has Feb 28 1971 in two places for MKAD's start date, even making a conceptual point connected with it in the Bombay text, i have switched it to 1971 in the wiki. That 1970 date was fairly out of place, now that the possibility is raised of all Feb-Mar 1971 (except those silly 1973 dates, which is another story). And it's easy to imagine a simple mistake somewhere along the line, getting the year wrong. Even in the sacred CD-ROM. -- doofus-9 06:50, 6 March 2016 (UTC)


Hovewer both first editions, Hindi and English, stated Feb 20, 1970...--DhyanAntar 06:54, 4 November 2019 (UTC)


List of Early Books: "Dimensions Beyond the Known-- 2/3/71 Hindi".--DhyanAntar 13:40, 16 June 2020 (UTC)


It seems dates available on Oshoganga. To be researched.--DhyanAntar 12:47, 4 July 2020 (UTC)


Oshoganga gives the same date as stated in 1979 ed. - 28 Feb 1971. "1970"-mistake appeared in 1971 Hindi edition and was corrected in 1979 big edition.

Jagdish (image on the right) confirmes this date. It seems his afternoon time is more accurate as Osho used to give intimate talks in afternoon time, i will use it for events.--DhyanAntar 06:22, 3 December 2020 (UTC)

A lotus emerges

Shailendra has kindly supplied material connected with the Rebel edition of MKAD. His edition he says is the 7th and was published in 2006. It is probably quite similar to the 1988 Tao edition, as its page count is very close, assuming one page for each of 39 letters in the last chapter. © is 1979.

The TOC below makes it clear that MKAD incorporated a number of other books, including the familiar Gahre and Jyotish, as well as the presumed Nav-Sannyas and a "surprise" -- to yr Western editors -- Main Kaun Hun. And a completely new entrant, Amrit Vani, about which so far nothing is known.

It can be seen that many of the mysteries and confusing and apparently ill-fitting "facts" considered above are resolved in this TOC. In general, Shailendra points out that there was a trend, even before Pune Two, toward consolidating smaller books and booklets into higher quality larger productions, giving the collections the name of one of the components. MKAD seems to have been well suited and placed for this trend to unfold in its name.

A small note about the chapter titles below: There are minor differences between a few of the titles below and their presentation in the TOC's of their separate books. These may even include errors. And with two particular words, i was unable to duplicate their presentation in the image of MKAD's contents. Possibly this reflects a change in the fashion of how particular consonant pairs are joined. The two words are underlined below, in ch 6 and 33.

Details about the rest of it, how the various "problems" in the preceding sections above are resolved, can be found below the TOC.

     मैं कहता आंखन देखी

1. सत्य सार्वभौम है . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1
2. चिन्मय कौन? अजन्मा क्या? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25
3. आकाश जैसा शाश्वत है सत्य . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 49
4. धर्म की गति और तेज हो! . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 73

गहरे पानी पैठ

5. मंदिर के आंतरिक अर्थ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 91
6. तीर्थ: परम की गुह्य यात्रा . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .113
7. तिलक-टीके: तृतीय नेत्र की अभिव्यंजना . . . . . . .143
8. मूर्ति-पूजा: मूर्त से अमूर्त की ओर . . . . . . . . . . . .167

ज्योतिष

9. ज्योतिष: अद्वैत का विज्ञान . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .193
10. ज्योतिष अर्थात अध्यात्म . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .215

मैं कौन हूं

11. मैं कौन हूं? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .237
12. धर्म क्या है? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .243
13. विज्ञान की अग्नि में धर्म और विश्वास . . . . . . . 245
14. मनुष्य का विज्ञान . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .251
15. विचार के जन्म के लिए : विचारों से मुक्ति . . . . 255
16. जीएं और जानें . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 265
17. शिक्षा का लक्ष्य . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .269
18. जीवन-संपदा का अधिकार . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 273
19. समाधि योग . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .277
20. जीवन की अदृश्य जड़ें . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 281
21. अहिंसा क्या है? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 285

XII

 

22. आनंद की दिशा . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .289
23. मांगो और मिलेगा . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 295
24. प्रेम ही प्रभु है . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 301
25. नीति, भय और प्रेम . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .305
26. अहिंसा का अर्थ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .309
27. मैं मृत्‍यु सिखाता हूं . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 313

अमृत वाणी

28. यह मन क्या है? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 317
29. जो बोएंगे बीज वही काटेंगे फसल . . . . . . . . . . . 327
30. मृत्यु और परलोक . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 335
31. भगवत्-प्रेम . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .343
32. जागते-जागते . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 351
33. ब्रह्मा के दो रूप . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 361

नव-संन्यास क्या?

34. नव-संन्यास का सूत्रपात . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 373
35. संन्यास और संसार . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .393
36. संन्यास के फूल : संसार की भूमि में . . . . . . . . . .409
37. संन्यास का एक नया अभियान . . . . . . . . . . . . .423
38. सावधिक संन्यास की धारणा. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 435
39. संन्यास का निर्णय और ध्यान में छलांग . . . . . . 439
40. संन्यास : नयी दिशा, नया बोध . . . . . . . . . . . . .443
41. आनंद व अहोभाव में डूबा हुआ नव-संन्यास . . . . .451
42. पूरब की श्रेष्ठतम देन : संन्यास . . . . . . . . . . . . 467
43. पत्र-पाथेय : संन्यासियों के लिए . . . . . . . . . . . . 471


XIII

It is evident now that as MKAD evolved over the years, it accumulated more and more fellow-travelers, and this is reflected in the numbers. And the English translations of MKAD and Gahre -- the sixes -- have been completely irrelevant to Hindi publishing. The two Jyotish chapters which ostensibly "migrated" from MKAD to Gahre -- though really only in translation -- are back in the fold, and audiowise have possibly always been (the case anyway at Osho World's bundle of ten).

And Tao Vision's thirteen? This is the same package as OW's ten, plus three of what they call "Sannyas". As it happens, a recent find at osho.com of an audiobook offering of three discourses under Nav-Sannyas corresponds well with this, and its titles match those of chapters 40, 41 and 42 in the TOC above (and for a bonus, all the titles in the Nav-Sannyas Kya section above match those of Diamond's 2007 hard copy).

Of course, all of Diamond's apparently outrageous numbers appear to be borne out. The first chapter of their Nav-Sannyas is indeed shown right here to be ch 34 of MKAD. What's not to like about this?

Amrit Vani will have to remain an unknown entity for a while. No search has turned up anything on it. Many offerings for this and that version of Osho "Amrit Vani", when checked out, have turned out to be not relevant, as both Amrit and Vani are somewhat generic terms connected with the words (written or spoken) of the saints and other spiritual figures. Even the individual discourse titles do not ring any bells. So it goes. It's all good. -- doofus-9 17:21, 26 February 2017 (UTC)


The known dates for (the first 4 chapters) of this book, can they go into the timeline? See also Dimensions Beyond the Known. --Sugit (talk) 13:21, 30 January 2018 (UTC)


Can't see why not, go for it! -- doofus-9 17:10, 30 January 2018 (UTC)


Shailendra - Osho's Hindi books (source document): "43 talks, 1970."--DhyanAntar 10:37, 16 June 2020 (UTC)


Place of ch.15 is Jabalpur, source Manuscripts ~ Vichar Ke Liye Vicharon Se Mukti (विचार के लिए विचारों से मुक्ति).--DhyanAntar 18:02, 15 June 2020 (UTC)

English Translation?

What is the name of this book in English? I see the hindi version of this book is for sale on eBay, but since I'm unable to read that language, I'm wondering if there is a version in the English language? Swamisitar (talk) 11:49, 16 March 2020 (UTC)


4-chapter version of this book is translated to English as Dimensions Beyond the Known (first 4 chapters).--DhyanAntar 14:40, 16 March 2020 (UTC)

Curious Question: would there be any value in purchasing an original copy of Rajneesh, Acharya: Main Kehta Ankhan Dekhi. Jeevan Jagriti. 1971. 136p and paying someone to translate the entire booklet into English? Is there any part of Rajneesh, Acharya: Main Kehta Ankhan Dekhi. Jeevan Jagriti. 1971. 136p that was not translated into English? Are there any booklets or parts of booklets OSHO produced which were not translated into English? I would be interested in funding in a non-commercial manner any translation work of any of his non-English books which have never been translated into English. Any thought on this matter? Swamisitar (talk) 01:08, 17 March 2020 (UTC)
There is nothing in the 1971 four-chapter edition that has not been translated, but there are many (most) Hindi original books that have not been translated. However to make a project out of it, however "well-intentioned", would run afoul of the claimed copyright holders, who ARE translating the old untranslated books but at a very slow pace, eking it out over decades, so as not to oversaturate the market supposedly. And you also run the risk of getting a poor quality translation. -- good luck! -- doofus-9 08:53, 17 March 2020 (UTC)